Chaplain Timothy Dolan: Cardinal Dolan Hired by NYPD

Cardinal Timothy Dolan Takes on New Role as Co-Lead of NYPD Chaplains Unit

In a surprising yet fitting development for one of New York City's most prominent religious figures, Cardinal Timothy Dolan has been appointed as co-lead of the New York Police Department's (NYPD) chaplains unit. The announcement, expected from Police Commissioner Jessica S. Tisch on Tuesday, February 10, 2026, pairs the retired Archbishop of New York with Rev. A.R. Bernard, founder of the Christian Cultural Center in Brooklyn, to guide the department's spiritual support team.

Cardinal Dolan, aged 76, recently concluded over 16 years as head of the Archdiocese of New York, where he was succeeded by Bishop Ronald Hicks. Known for his approachable demeanor, media presence, and ability to bridge divides in a diverse city, Dolan has long been a fixture in New York's public life. His new role, which he will undertake part-time, marks a transition from leading one of the largest Catholic archdioceses in the United States to providing pastoral care directly to the men and women of the nation's largest police force.

The NYPD chaplains unit offers critical spiritual and emotional support to officers, their families, and sometimes victims or community members affected by incidents. Chaplains respond to crises, conduct blessings, offer counseling, and serve as a source of moral guidance in high-stress environments. With Dolan's appointment alongside Rev. Bernard—a respected leader in the Black church community—the unit gains leaders who represent key faith traditions in New York, potentially strengthening trust and outreach across the city's multicultural landscape.

Commissioner Tisch's decision highlights the ongoing need for robust chaplaincy services amid the challenges police officers face daily, from routine patrols to major emergencies. Sources describe Dolan and Bernard as "two of the most righteous people this city has ever known," praising their faith, compassion, and wisdom as qualities officers rely on in difficult moments.

This move comes at a time when Dolan, no longer bound by full-time archdiocesan duties, can dedicate his energies to hands-on ministry. His familiarity with first responders—built through years of attending memorials, blessings, and community events—positions him well for this service-oriented role. For many, it's a natural extension of his pastoral heart, now channeled toward those who protect and serve.

As New York continues to navigate complex social issues, having figures like Cardinal Dolan in supportive roles for law enforcement could foster greater dialogue between police and faith communities. The official installation is set to proceed soon, marking an exciting new chapter for both the cardinal and the NYPD.

Sources:

- The New York Times: "Tisch to Name Leaders of Catholic and Black Churches as N.Y.P.D. Chaplains" (February 9, 2026) - https://www.nytimes.com/2026/02/09/nyregion/nypd-chaplains-tisch-dolan-bernard.html

- New York Post: "Cardinal Timothy Dolan and Rev. A.R. Bernard to serve as NYPD co-chaplains: officials" (February 9, 2026) - https://nypost.com/2026/02/09/us-news/cardinal-timothy-dolan-and-rev-a-r-bernard-to-serve-as-nypd-co-chaplains-officials

- amNewYork: "Cardinal Timothy Dolan to co-chaplain NYPD, commissioner Tisch is expected to announce" - https://www.amny.com/lifestyle/faith/cardinal-timothy-dolan-chaplain-nypd

- PIX11: "Cardinal Dolan, Rev. Bernard to lead NYPD Chaplains Unit" - https://pix11.com/news/local-news/cardinal-dolan-rev-bernard-to-lead-nypd-chaplains-unit

- EWTN News: "Cardinal Dolan to co-lead New York Police Department's chaplains' unit" - https://www.ewtnnews.com/world/us/cardinal-dolan-to-be-named-co-lead-of-nypd-chaplain-unit

The Vatican to Soon Announce the Beatification of Venerable Fulton J. Sheen

Exciting News for Catholics Worldwide: The Vatican to Soon Announce the Beatification of Venerable Fulton J. Sheen

Dear readers,

Today brings a moment of great joy and anticipation for the Church! Reliable reports indicate that the Holy See is expected to formally announce in the coming weeks a date for the beatification of Venerable Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen, the beloved American prelate, Emmy-winning televangelist, and pioneer of Catholic media evangelization.

This long-awaited development marks a significant step forward in Sheen's cause for sainthood, which has been underway since 2002 when the Diocese of Peoria opened the process. Sheen, who died in 1979, was declared Venerable by Pope Benedict XVI in 2012 for his heroic virtues. In July 2019, Pope Francis approved a miracle attributed to his intercession—the inexplicable recovery of a stillborn child in 2010 after his parents prayed for Sheen's help—clearing the theological path for beatification.

The ceremony was originally scheduled for December 21, 2019, but was postponed just weeks before due to concerns from the Diocese of Rochester (where Sheen briefly served as bishop from 1966–1969) amid ongoing investigations into clergy abuse handling in New York. Sheen's supporters, including the Diocese of Peoria, maintained that he had been thoroughly exonerated and never placed children in harm's way.

The resolution of the Diocese of Rochester's bankruptcy in September 2025, including a substantial settlement for abuse survivors, has now removed the final major obstacle. Sources close to the process report that Sheen's beatification is likely to take place in September 2026, possibly in Peoria, Illinois—where he was ordained a priest in 1919 and where his cause originated.

Archbishop Sheen remains one of the most influential Catholic figures in modern American history. Through radio programs like The Catholic Hour and television shows such as Life Is Worth Living (which drew millions of viewers and earned him Emmy Awards), he brought timeless truths of the faith to a mass audience with clarity, wit, and profound insight. His legacy continues to inspire countless faithful today.

This news is a reminder of God's grace working through holy lives, even across decades. As we await the official Vatican announcement, let us pray for the intercession of Venerable Fulton Sheen and give thanks for the Church's careful discernment in recognizing sanctity.

Venerable Fulton J. Sheen, pray for us!

Stay tuned for the official confirmation from the Vatican—may this be the beginning of many graces through Blessed Fulton Sheen's intercession! 🙏 

Sources:

- The Pillar: ["‘Back on the air’ - Fulton Sheen beatification to be announced"](https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/back-on-the-air-fulton-sheen-beatification) (January 13, 2026)

- CatholicVote: ["Report: Vatican expected to announce beatification date for Ven. Fulton Sheen"](https://catholicvote.org/report-vatican-expected-to-announce-beatification-date-for-ven-fulton-sheen) (January 13, 2026)

- Infovaticana: ["The beatification of Fulton Sheen returns to the Vatican’s agenda"](https://infovaticana.com/en/2026/01/13/the-beatification-of-fulton-sheen-returns-to-the-vaticans-agenda) (January 13, 2026)

- Wikipedia (Fulton J. Sheen entry, updated as of January 2026): Reports the upcoming announcement following earlier developments.

Cardinal Dolan vs Hispanic Catholics

Cardinal Dolan's Final Act: Striking Back at Yonkers' Hispanic Community

In the waning days of his tenure as Archbishop of New York, Cardinal Timothy Dolan has issued what many are calling a parting shot at one of the archdiocese's most vibrant Hispanic communities: the parishioners of St. Mary's Church (officially the Church of the Immaculate Conception) in Yonkers. Just days after Pope Leo XIV accepted his resignation and appointed Bishop Ronald Hicks as his successor, Dolan released a new decree reaffirming the merger of St. Mary's parish into another, effectively sidelining the historic church that has served immigrants for 175 years. This move has reignited accusations that Dolan has long been unfriendly toward the growing Hispanic population in the archdiocese, prioritizing administrative consolidation over pastoral care for Latino Catholics.

St. Mary's Church, often dubbed the "Cathedral of the Hudson River Valley," stands as a symbol of immigrant resilience in Yonkers. Founded in 1848, it has historically welcomed waves of newcomers—Irish, Italian, and now predominantly Hispanic, with many parishioners from Dominican, Mexican, and other Latin American backgrounds. The community is known for its outreach to new immigrants, providing food, clothing, and support amid ongoing arrivals. Yet, under Dolan's leadership, the church has faced repeated threats of closure or merger, culminating in this latest decree that critics say defies a prior Vatican reversal.

The controversy traces back years. Dolan sought an "extinctive union" merging Immaculate Conception Parish (St. Mary's) with St. Peter-St. Denis Parish, meaning St. Mary's would lose its independent status. Largely Hispanic parishioners appealed, arguing the merger disregarded their cultural and spiritual needs. After Dolan rejected their appeal, they escalated to the Vatican's Dicastery for the Clergy, which revoked his decree earlier this year—the first such reversal in the Archdiocese of New York's history and only the ninth in modern U.S. Catholic history.

Undeterred, Dolan has now issued a new decree, described by local reports as disobedient to the Vatican. In it, he references "white flight to the suburbs, together with a substantial immigration of Hispanics," framing demographic shifts in a way that some see as dismissive. The decree also eliminates Spanish-language Masses previously offered, leaving only limited bilingual options initiated by parishioners themselves. Attendance at St. Mary's is reportedly at 80% capacity, with growth among Hispanic members—hardly the profile of a dying parish.

This isn't an isolated incident. Throughout Dolan's 16-year tenure (2009-2025), critics have pointed to a pattern of actions that appear hostile or indifferent to Hispanic Catholics, who now form a significant portion of the archdiocese's faithful. The Archdiocese of New York serves about 2.8 million Catholics, with Hispanics comprising a growing demographic—nearly one million in the region, by some estimates. Yet, Dolan's policies on parish reorganizations have disproportionately affected immigrant-heavy urban parishes.

The "Making All Things New" planning process (2010-2015) led to numerous mergers and closures, often in areas with strong Latino presence. In Yonkers alone, multiple churches serving immigrant communities faced consolidation. While financial pressures—declining attendance overall, priest shortages, and massive settlements for clergy abuse claims (over $300 million announced in 2025)—are cited as justifications, critics argue these decisions ignored the vitality of Hispanic parishes. St. Mary's, for instance, was deemed in need of $10 million in repairs, a figure disputed by independent engineers as exaggerated. The archdiocese banned the parish from fundraising for repairs, further fueling suspicions.

Broader criticisms highlight Dolan's silence on immigration issues affecting Hispanics. Despite the national debate over migrant rights and policies, Dolan remained notably quiet, even as other bishops advocated strongly. His associations drew scrutiny too: praising conservative figures criticized for anti-Latino rhetoric indirectly tied him to broader insensitivity.

Perhaps most emblematic of perceived unfriendliness is Dolan's approach to episcopal appointments. Despite the rapid growth of Hispanic Catholics, he appointed mostly white auxiliary bishops during his tenure. It wasn't until 2022—late in his leadership—that he welcomed the appointment of Bishop Joseph Espaillat, a Dominican-American priest, as auxiliary bishop. Espaillat, born in New York to Dominican immigrants, became the first Dominican-origin bishop in the U.S. and the youngest at the time.

While celebrated by many as a milestone, some viewed it as tokenism—a superficial gesture amid years of underrepresentation. Espaillat's appointment came from Pope Francis, not Dolan directly, and followed calls for greater Latino leadership. Critics noted it as the only such appointment under Dolan, despite Hispanics being "not just part of the Catholic Church in New York, they are the Church here," as Dolan himself once acknowledged in a Lenten message.

Espaillat's rise has been refreshing for many Dominican Catholics, who see him as a bridge to younger, urban Latinos. Known for his engaging style—rapping, podcasting on "Sainthood in the City," and youth ministry—he represents the future. Yet, his appointment highlighted the delay: why only one, and so late? Where is the Puerto Rican bishop? Puerto Rican Catholics paved the wave for other Hispanics by joining the late Bishop Francis Garmendia of Basque decent as he founded the Charistmatic Center. 

Dolan's defenders point to efforts like supporting Hispanic ministry, Lenten videos in Spanish, and a mural at St. Patrick's Cathedral celebrating immigrants. He oversaw outreach and acknowledged Latinos' importance. But actions like the Yonkers decree overshadow these, especially as his successor, Bishop Hicks—a missionary with experience in Latin America and fluency in Spanish—signals a potential shift toward greater inclusion.

Hicks, who has expressed a "great heart" for the Latino community, takes over in February 2026. Parishioners at St. Mary's are appealing Dolan's latest decree to the Vatican again, hoping the new leadership brings reconciliation.

This episode raises deeper questions about the Church's adaptation to demographic reality. As white attendance declines in urban areas, Hispanic Catholics sustain many parishes. Policies that merge or close these without robust alternatives risk alienating the faithful keeping the Church alive.

Cardinal Dolan's legacy is complex: media-savvy, charismatic, defender against secular threats. But in Yonkers, many Hispanic Catholics feel his final act was one of retribution—striking back at a community that dared appeal to Rome. Whether valid under canon law or not, it leaves a bitter taste as he exits.

The Church in New York stands at a crossroads. With Hicks incoming, perhaps a more welcoming era for Hispanics begins. For St. Mary's parishioners, the fight continues—not just for a building, but for recognition that their faith matters.

 References and Links

1. "Cardinal Dolan Takes a Final Shot at Yonkers and its Hispanic Community" - Yonkers Times (December 22, 2025): https://yonkerstimes.com/cardinal-dolan-takes-a-final-shot-at-yonkers-and-its-hispanic-community/

2. "Cardinal Dolan Destroys Archdiocese of NY" - Sacerdotus Blog (2025): https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/12/cardinal-dolan-destroys-archdiocese-of.html (Discusses auxiliary appointments and perceptions of tokenism regarding Bishop Espaillat)

3. "Joseph Espaillat is New York's first Dominican bishop" - National Catholic Reporter: https://www.ncronline.org/news/opinion/joseph-espaillat-new-yorks-first-dominican-bishop-what-does-mean-our-church

4. "Hispanic Community in Yonkers Rallies to Save St. Mary’s Church" - Yonkers Times (2024): https://yonkerstimes.com/hispanic-community-in-yonkers-rallies-to-save-st-marys-church/

5. "Pope Leo replaces New York's Cardinal Dolan in shake-up of US Church" - Reuters (December 18, 2025): https://www.reuters.com/world/us/pope-leo-replaces-new-yorks-cardinal-dolan-shake-up-us-church-2025-12-18/

6. Wikipedia entry on Joseph A. Espaillat: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_A._Espaillat (For background on his 2022 appointment)

7. Archdiocese of New York official statements and historical parish data referenced from various reports on "Making All Things New" reorganizations.

Cardinal Dolan Destroys Archdiocese of NY

Cardinal Timothy Dolan: A Tenure Marked by Controversy and Decline in the Archdiocese of New York

 Introduction

Cardinal Timothy Michael Dolan, born on February 6, 1950, in St. Louis, Missouri, has been a prominent figure in the American Catholic Church for decades. Ordained a priest in 1976, he rose through the ranks, serving as auxiliary bishop of St. Louis, archbishop of Milwaukee from 2002 to 2009, and then as archbishop of New York starting in 2009. Elevated to cardinal in 2012 by Pope Benedict XVI, Dolan has been known for his jovial personality, media presence, and efforts to engage with contemporary society. However, his leadership of the Archdiocese of New York, one of the largest and most influential dioceses in the United States, has been fraught with criticisms. Detractors argue that under his watch, the archdiocese has experienced significant decline, marked by church and school closures, mishandling of sexual abuse scandals, liturgical irregularities, discriminatory policies, and a perceived softening on key moral issues. This essay examines these claims, drawing on documented events and statistics to assess how Dolan's tenure may have contributed to what some see as the "ruining" of the archdiocese. Spanning from his installation in 2009 to his retirement in 2025, this period saw profound changes in the Church amid broader societal shifts, including secularization, demographic changes, and legal reforms in New York.

Dolan's arrival in New York was initially met with optimism. He succeeded Cardinal Edward Egan, inheriting a diocese serving approximately 2.8 million Catholics across 296 parishes in Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, and seven upstate counties. The archdiocese boasted a robust network of institutions, including schools, charities, and seminaries. Yet, over the next 16 years, critics contend that Dolan's decisions exacerbated existing challenges, leading to institutional shrinkage and eroded trust among the faithful. This analysis will explore key areas of contention: financial and structural decisions resulting in closures, liturgical affronts, responses to sexual abuse, treatment of whistleblowers, deaconate policies, seminarian declines, stances on social issues like abortion and same-sex marriage, bishop appointments, euthanasia legalization, relations with controversial priests, allowances for gay pride activities in parishes, statistical evidence of decline, public optics issues, and handling of wayward priests. While Dolan has defended his actions as necessary adaptations, the cumulative impact paints a picture of a leadership style that prioritized pragmatism over tradition, alienating conservative Catholics while failing to stem broader losses.

 Church and School Closures Amid Fundraising Appeals

One of the most visible signs of decline under Dolan has been the widespread closure of churches and schools, often justified by financial constraints and shifting demographics. In 2014, Dolan announced a major restructuring plan called "Making All Things New," which merged 110 parishes into 55, effectively closing dozens of worship sites. This move was presented as a way to consolidate resources and better serve the faithful, but it displaced communities and erased historical landmarks. For instance, some churches were shuttered entirely except for occasional events, leaving parishioners without local access to sacraments. Many of these churhces were leveled and turned into apartments. Take St. Augustine, St. Francis of Assisi and Our Lady of Pity in the Bronx as examples.  So the archdiocese became a landlord for tenants instead of a source of faith and hope.  The focus shifted from spirituality to the mundane.  Critics argue this contradicted the spirit of Vatican II's emphasis on community-based worship, as parishes are meant to be vibrant centers of faith life.

School closures have been equally devastating. In 2023, Dolan oversaw the shuttering of 12 Catholic schools in New York City, citing enrollment declines and financial unsustainability. Earlier, in 2018, seven schools were closed, affecting thousands of students and families who relied on these institutions for affordable, values-based education. These decisions came despite annual fundraising efforts like the Cardinal's Annual Stewardship Appeal, which promised to support parishes and schools. Parishes were instructed to promote the appeal, including through videos featuring Dolan, often played during or around Mass times. This practice raised eyebrows, as it interrupted the sacred liturgy, potentially violating Vatican II's Sacrosanctum Concilium, which prohibits additions or removals from the approved rites to preserve the integrity of worship. Such appeals, while common, were seen by some as commercializing the Mass, turning it into a fundraising platform rather than a pure act of devotion. Despite pledges that donations would bolster local institutions, closures continued, leading to accusations that funds were mismanaged or redirected to other priorities, such as legal settlements for abuse claims. Many of the Catholic schools shuttered are not being rented out to the Public School system, again, the archdiocese has become a landlord instead of a source to educate children with faith-filled education. 

The irony is stark: while parishes broadcasted Dolan's messages assuring support for education and community, the archdiocese proceeded with closures, eroding trust. In 2025, amid ongoing economic pressures, more schools faced viability studies, with additional closures announced independently.

 Poor Response to Sexual Abuse Claims

Dolan's handling of sexual abuse allegations has been a flashpoint of criticism, echoing broader Church scandals. Prior to New York, as archbishop of Milwaukee, he authorized payments of up to $20,000 to abusive priests to encourage their departure, a practice experts noted was common but controversial, as it could be seen as hush money. In New York, similar issues arose. In 2018, Dolan released a list of credibly accused clergy, including auxiliary bishop John Jenik, but critics argued this was reactive, coming amid public pressure rather than proactive reform.

The archdiocese faced lawsuits under New York's Child Victims Act, leading to a $300 million fund in 2025 for victims, funded by budget cuts and asset sales. However, groups like the Center for Constitutional Rights condemned Dolan's appointment in 2009, citing his Milwaukee record of failing to report admissions by offenders. In 2018, amid the Pennsylvania grand jury report, Dolan called the scandals a "disaster," but his responses were deemed insufficient by survivors who sought greater transparency and accountability. This perceived leniency fostered a culture where abuse claims were not aggressively pursued, further damaging the archdiocese's reputation and contributing to declining participation.

 Dismissal of Seminarian Whistleblower

A particularly egregious incident involved the dismissal of seminarian Anthony Gorgia who was accepted to St. Joseph's Seminary but was sent to Pontifical North American College in Rome to study. Gorgia reported witnessing a priest kissing another man Pontical North American College (see: https://saveourseminarians.wordpress.com/). Gorgia, a whistleblower, was expelled in 2020, allegedly for "slow progress in human formation," but critics, including commentators like Gene Gomulka, argued it was retaliation for exposing homosexual activity. This case highlighted Dolan's alleged tolerance for misconduct while punishing those who speak out, contradicting Church teachings on integrity in formation. Such actions discouraged reporting, perpetuating a toxic environment in seminaries and contributing to vocational crises. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyCiI5kPTkI)

 Deaconate Policy and Exclusion of the Poor

Dolan's policies for permanent deacons have been criticized for favoring wealthy men over the poor, contradicting Pope Francis's vision of a "Church of the poor for the poor." While the archdiocese's program emphasizes service to the needy, requirements mandate job stability and sufficient income to support families, effectively excluding unemployed or benefit-dependent men. This creates a "club" of affluent deacons, unlike early Church figures like St. Stephen, who served the marginalized and who were poor themselves. By prioritizing an economic test, Dolan's administration overlooked devout men on SNAP or HRA benefits, limiting diversity and authenticity in diaconal ministry. It is no suprised that the majority of permanent deacons are white affluent men, many who are laywers, doctors and businessmen.  

 Decline in Seminarians and Admission Standards

Seminarian numbers plummeted under Dolan, with priests halving since 1970, a trend accelerating in New York. In 2009, the archdiocese had robust enrollment, but by 2025, recruitment efforts yielded mixed results, with fewer ordinations. Critics allege Dolan allowed candidates with neurotic tendencies or homosexual orientations, contrary to Vatican guidelines, though direct evidence is limited.  We only have accounts from other seminarians, priests and parishioners who have witnessed and/or experienced bad behavior. The overall decline reflects broader issues like scandal fatigue and cultural shifts.

 Ignoring Key Social Issues

Dolan has been accused of soft-pedaling on abortion and same-sex marriage. While he lobbied against abortion expansions and criticized the 2019 Reproductive Health Act, some felt his responses were tepid as opposed to the late Cardinal O'Connor who was willing to be arrested to defend life. On same-sex marriage, legalized in 2011, he opposed but admitted the Church was "outmarketed." His decision to allow LGBT groups in the 2015 St. Patrick's Day Parade was seen as capitulation. Under his watch, New York passed extreme abortion laws and, in 2025, legalized euthanasia for terminally ill, with Dolan opposing but critics saying too late. 

 Bishop Appointments and Demographics

Despite Hispanics comprising a growing demographic, Dolan appointed mostly white auxiliaries, with Bishop Joseph Espaillat as a Dominican Latino in 2022, seen by some as tokenism. This overlooked the archdiocese's shifting population, alienating minorities. Where are the African American bishops, the Puerto Rican bishops, the Mexican bishops?

 Softness on Controversial Priests

Dolan was lenient with defrocked priest Frank Pavone, initially supporting before cutting ties in 2014 over financial issues, but not addressing his extremism sooner. With Fr. James Martin, Dolan endorsed his LGBT outreach, sending greetings to conferences.  Martin was never rebuked for his statements and stance that has caused scandal and is in odds with Catholic teaching on homosexuality. 

 Gay Pride in Parishes

Parishes under Dolan hosted pride events, displaying flags and celebrating Masses, seen as endorsing sin.  Such parishes like St. Francis of Assisi and St. Paul in Manhattan are examples.  

 Statistical Shrinkage

In 2009, the archdiocese had around 584 diocesan priests, 296 parishes, and over 200 schools. By 2025, priests numbered fewer at about 236, parishes stabilized at 296 but with mergers, schools dropped to 153 with 50,000 students, reflecting decline. Deacons and religious also decreased, mirroring local trends. At one point the Catholic population in the archdiocese was 2.8 million and is down to 2.6 million. 

 Bad Optics and Personal Conduct

Dolan's photos with Rockettes in revealing attire raised modesty concerns. Anecdotes of invasive embraces made some uncomfortable, though not formally documented as widespread complaints. The cardinal was even mocked on social media for violating the personal space of a religious sister who has a face of discomfort in photos.  He also has a tendency of being too touchy-feely, placing his elbow and weight on the shoulders of otheres and placing his arm around people.  

You can see the video of the Cardinal here with Sister Mary Juan visibly uncomfortable:

Cardinal Dolan X account

I’m here with Sister Mary Juan at the Casa Santa Maria, which is not only a residence for priests but also the visitor’s office for Americans visiting Rome! @thegnewsroom https://t.co/ZgxxcOqklj pic.twitter.com/vFUYgcAi2w

— Cardinal Dolan (@CardinalDolan) April 10, 2024

Here you can see reaction from Catholics and non-Catholics who felt the cardinal oversteeped persaonal bounderies with the religious sister:

Kinda creepy Tim

— Fred Simon (@FredSimonTLM) April 11, 2024

Stop touching her. She's not into you, dude.

— Victoria Brownworth (@VABVOX) April 11, 2024

You’re pretty handsy with the sister. Very disrespectful

— T.A.R.S. 🏴🇻🇦 (@TARSRel0aded) April 10, 2024

Controlling, Creepy & Inappropriate on every level.

— TXDad (@TXpilotDad) April 10, 2024

The body language of Sister Mary shows she's uncomfortable. I was uncomfortable just watching it with out sound. I then listened to the video thinking it was maybe an incorrect observation on my part. But you can clearly hear she's uncomfortable in the tones of her voice.…

— Texas Hodler $8.01 (@TexasHodlerMom) April 11, 2024

This is creepy.

Why are you holding her like this and why are you touching her all the time?

— Alen Koman 🇻🇦🇸🇮☧ (@ScutumFidei_) April 11, 2024

Predator

— Lindsey Boylan (@LindseyBoylan) April 11, 2024

Dear Cardinal, as a woman myself, I would feel very uncomfortable having my hand held this long from anyone other than my husband. She wouldn’t pull her hand away if uncomfortable because it’d seem rude....Perhaps you didn’t know...but it’s something to avoid in the future.

— Kristine (@Bake_pray_fish) April 11, 2024

Gentlemen keep their hands to themselves. How much more so for a Bishop of the Catholic Church?

— Simply Grandma Dawn (@DawnR60) April 10, 2024

Let her hand go. It’s not normal. You’re not just invading her space you’re keeping her captive. If she struggled on camera it would make you look bad so she tries to smile along. It’s what women do in these situations.

— Spirit Unbounded (@SpiritUnbounded) April 11, 2024

This kind of proximity is never normal. Not even for male and female relatives. Such a strange vibe.

— Steel (@Ite_Ad_Thomam) April 11, 2024

Stop holding her hands for so long. Just stop. 🛑 You’re making her uncomfortable

— A.A. 🇻🇦✝️🇺🇸 (@madlabrador_) April 10, 2024

 Lack of Response to Wayward Priests

In the Miqueli scandal, Dolan was accused of knowing about embezzlement and misconduct but responding slowly, with clergy covering up. Parishoners at St. Frances de Chantal had to organize themselves to seek justice from the alleged theft and sexual coverup.  Miqueli would die years later at his home in New Jersey where he allegedly lived with a muscular boyfriend without any punishment.  See: Facebook

Other controversies

Other controversies surrounding Dolan are the funeral for a trans activist that was done without proper vetting. The "canonization" of Charlie Kirk by Dolan who compared him to St. Paul bringing the Sister of Charity to condemn his statement (see: Sisters of Charity nuns criticize Cardinal Dolan's comments likening Charlie Kirk to a saint).  The lack of response regarding the Met Gala where Catholic vestments were mimicked and displayed in vulgar manners.

 Dolan vs Hispanic Catholics in Yonkers

In a controversial move just before his replacement as Archbishop of New York, Cardinal Timothy Dolan issued a new decree aiming to merge or effectively close St. Mary’s Church (Church of the Immaculate Conception) in Yonkers, the city's oldest Roman Catholic parish founded in 1848. This decree revives a previous attempt that was successfully appealed by the largely Hispanic parishioners to the Vatican, resulting in a rare revocation—the first for the New York Archdiocese and only the ninth in modern U.S. Catholic history. Despite the Vatican's restoration of the parish, Dolan had refused to appoint a pastor, and the new decree eliminates Spanish-language masses while citing demographic shifts like "white flight to the suburbs" alongside increased Hispanic immigration. The church, operating at 80% capacity, has long served as a vital resource for immigrants, providing food, clothing, and outreach.

The article here (Cardinal Dolan Takes a Final Shot at Yonkers and its Hispanic Community | Yonkers Times) portrays Dolan's action as a parting affront to Yonkers and its Hispanic community, highlighting a history of tension, including a dismissed Archdiocese lawsuit against the city after it granted the church landmark status. Parishioners, supported by groups like St. Mary’s Friends, Inc., plan to appeal the latest decree to the Vatican again, questioning its validity under Canon Law. This comes amid broader changes, with Pope Leo XIV replacing Dolan with Bishop Ronald Hicks effective February 2026, and the new pope's vocal criticism of U.S. immigration policies contrasting with Dolan's perceived silence on the issue.

Conclusion

Dolan's tenure, ending in 2025, left the Archdiocese of New York smaller and more divided. While he navigated complex challenges, criticisms of mismanagement, moral compromises, and institutional losses suggest a legacy of decline. His successor faces the task of rebuilding.

 References and Sources

0. Making All Things New Decisions Announced - https://archny.org/making-all-things-new-decisions-announced/

1. Cardinal Dolan Issues Parish Decrees - The Good Newsroom - https://thegoodnewsroom.org/cardinal-dolan-issues-parish-decrees-september-5-2025/

2. [PDF] Decree on the Merger of the Parishes of Corpus Christi and Notre ... - https://archny.org/wp-content/uploads/Decree-on-the-Merger-of-the-Parishes-of-Corpus-Christi-and-Notre-Dame-North-Manhattan.pdf

3. Mergers of 31 additional New York City Catholic churches announced - https://abc7ny.com/post/mergers-of-31-additional-new-york-city-catholic-churches-announced/705868/

4. Painful Parish Consolidations in New York - National Catholic Register - https://www.ncregister.com/news/painful-parish-consolidations-in-new-york

5. Cardinal Dolan unveils merger plans for Catholic parishes - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/groups/SullivanCountyPost/posts/8850302031760927/

6. New York archdiocese announces plans for parish mergers | News ... - https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=23109

7. [PDF] decree on the merger of the territorial parishes of saint john the baptist - http://archny.org/wp-content/uploads/Decree-on-the-Merger-of-the-Territorial-Parishes-of-Saint-John-the-Baptist-Most-Holy-Trinity-and-Saint-Ann-Yonkers-South-Westchester-New-York.pdf

8. Cardinal Timothy Dolan Details Parish Mergers & Closings - YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8ZKa9zwndc

9. Message from Cardinal Dolan: The Crisis Confronting All Schools - https://archny.org/ca-eng/

10. Cardinal says closing seven 'of our beloved schools' tough decision - https://www.ncronline.org/news/cardinal-says-closing-seven-our-beloved-schools-tough-decision

11. Cardinal Timothy Dolan on somber moment of closing Catholic ... - https://www.foxnews.com/video/6369192314112

12. Message from Cardinal Dolan - Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/csl-esp/csl-eng/

13. Timothy Cardinal Dolan - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1266567183494298&id=270721406325846

14. Timothy Cardinal Dolan discusses decision to close 12 NYC ... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mErMZ0m4Zv4

15. Citing finances, N.Y. Archdiocese to close 12 schools at end of ... - https://catholicreview.org/citing-finances-n-y-archdiocese-to-close-12-schools-at-end-of-academic-year/

16. Cardinal Dolan Reproaches Anti-Migrant Protestors at Closed ... - https://thegoodnewsroom.org/cardinal-dolan-chastens-anti-migrant-protestors-at-closed-catholic-school-site/

17. Announcements - Catholic Schools in the Archdiocese of New York - https://catholicschoolsny.org/announcements/

18. The Cardinal's Annual Stewardship Appeal Hosts Regional Major ... - https://vimeo.com/1086140880

19. 2025 Videos | The Cardinal's Annual Stewardship Appeal - https://cardinalsappeal.org/where-your-support-goes/2025-videos/

20. Message from the Cardinal 2022 Cardinal's Annual Stewardship ... - https://vimeo.com/662063774

21. 2025 Catholic Stewardship Appeal - YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uvQZqzCHIhE

22. The Cardinal's Stewardship Campaign 2024 - https://stmarykatonah.com/the-cardinals-stewardship-campaign-2024/

23. A Word from Cardinal Dolan: The Gift of Holy Orders - Vimeo - https://vimeo.com/1088012249

24. Cardinal Dolan's Video - Sacred Heart - Suffern, NY - https://sacredheartparish.org/transparency

25. Archdiocese of Milwaukee: Catholic Stewardship Appeal - YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7QrbJyw2KU

26. The Cardinal's Annual Stewardship Appeal - St. Augustine Church - https://staugny.org/cardinals-appeal

27. Home (Original Version) | The Cardinal's Annual Stewardship Appeal - https://cardinalsappeal.org/home/

28. Statement Of Timothy Cardinal Dolan On The Release Of His ... - https://archny.org/statement-of-timothy-cardinal-dolan-on-the-release-of-his-depostion-by-the-archdiocese-of-milwaukee/

29. Groups Condemn Appointment of Archbishop Dolan to Cardinal of ... - https://ccrjustice.org/home/press-center/press-releases/groups-condemn-appointment-archbishop-dolan-cardinal-new-york

30. In Milwaukee Post, Cardinal Authorized Paying Abusers - https://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/31/us/cardinal-authorized-payments-to-abusers.html

31. Dolan on sex abuse scandals: “This needs to haunt us” - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/60minutes/videos/dolan-on-sex-abuse-scandals-this-needs-to-haunt-us/1631217618233247/

32. Sexual abuse scandal in the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of ... - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_scandal_in_the_Roman_Catholic_Archdiocese_of_Milwaukee

33. Timothy Dolan warned Vatican of sex abuse scandal in Milwaukee ... - https://abc7ny.com/archive/9158554/

34. Cardinal Dolan goes on record regarding Milwaukee priest sex ... - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFoHoNaYfSg

35. N.Y. cardinal questioned in Milwaukee sex-abuse cases | Reuters - https://www.reuters.com/article/world/uk/ny-cardinal-questioned-in-milwaukee-sex-abuse-cases-idUSBRE91K04W/

36. Cardinal Dolan of the NewYork Archdiocese Announces $300 ... - https://www.facebook.com/groups/popefranc/posts/25730679303217243/

37. [PDF] 356 H Avenue Coronado, CA 92118 22 April 2020 Timothy Cardinal ... - http://www.gomulka.net/Dolan.pdf

38. Six U.S. Prelates in Need of Laicization - Clean The Church - https://cleanthechurch.com/six-u-s-prelates-in-need-of-laicization/

39. [PDF] 356 H Avenue Coronado, CA 92118 22 April 2020 Timothy Cardinal ... - http://www.gomulka.net/Nine.pdf

40. INGLORIOUS HISTORY OF ABUSE AND COVER-UPS - https://johneighteenthirtyseven.substack.com/p/inglorious-history-of-abuse-and-cover

41. In his defense, Rev. Michael Briese had written a ... - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/groups/217054878988540/posts/1657889391571741/

42. ADVOCATING, FREEDOM FIGHTER, PROFILING, BEING A ... - https://www.facebook.com/groups/846549332639721/posts/1796157594345552/

43. Diaconate Formation Program | Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/ministries-and-offices/vocations/diaconate-formation-program/

44. Diaconate Requirements - Roman Catholic Diocese of Syracuse - https://syracusediocese.org/diaconate-requirements

45. Careers - Open Positions - Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/career-opportunities/

46. Permanent Diaconate Program - St. Joseph's Seminary & College - https://dunwoodie.edu/permanent-diaconate-1

47. [PDF] GUIDELINES AND POLICIES - Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/wp-content/uploads/YFF-Policy-Manual-2020-%25E2%2580%2593-web.pdf

48. Formation of Deacons | Roman Catholic Diocese of Rochester - https://www.dor.org/vocations/deacons/formation-of-deacons/

49. Office of Diaconate Formation - Diocese of Brooklyn - https://dioceseofbrooklyn.org/offices/diaconate-formation/

50. Theological Formation - Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/ministries-and-offices/vocations/diaconate-formation-program/theological-formation/

51. [PDF] Deacon Personnel Policy Manual Diocese of Erie - https://www.eriercd.org/images/sections/deacons/pdf/policy-manual-draft.pdf

52. [PDF] Preamble The Formation of Permanent Deacons Diocese of ... - https://www.rcdony.org/images/HistoryofthePermanentDioconateVocations.pdf

53. Facing shortage, New York Archdiocese taps parishioners to spot ... - https://www.catholicherald.com/article/national/facing-shortage-new-york-archdiocese-taps-parishioners-to-spot-future-priests/

54. Facing shortage, New York Archdiocese taps parishioners to spot ... - https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/264511/facing-shortage-new-york-rchdiocese-taps-parishioners-to-spot-future-priests

55. Facing shortage, New York taps parishioners to spot future priests - https://wnycatholic.org/2025/06/05/facing-shortage-new-york-taps-parishioners-to-spot-future-priests/

56. Confirmed: Joliet's Bishop Hicks to NYC - The Pillar - https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/confirmed-joliets-bishop-hicks-to

57. [The Pillar] Confirmed: Joliet's Bishop Hicks to NYC : r/Catholicism - https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/1poe44d/the_pillar_confirmed_joliets_bishop_hicks_to_nyc/

58. Cardinal Dolan unveils merger plans for Catholic parishes - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/groups/SullivanCountyPost/posts/8850302031760927/

59. Cardinal Dolan: The Catholic Church has too many seminaries. - https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2023/08/28/cardinal-dolan-too-many-seminaries-245942/

60. Too many seminaries? A concern for subsidiarity - https://www.oursundayvisitor.com/too-many-seminaries-a-concern-for-subsidiarity/

61. Cardinal Timothy Dolan to step down as archbishop of New York, to ... - https://catholicvote.org/cardinal-timothy-dolan-stepping-down-as-archbishop-of-new-york-to-be-succeeded-by-bishop-ronald-hicks-of-joliet/

62. In the Archdiocese of New York, where ordinations to the priesthood ... - https://www.instagram.com/p/DKfkdskvE0n/

63. Cardinal Dolan: New Laws Restricting Abortion A Direct Response ... - https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/archbishop-dolan-new-laws-restricting-abortion-a-direct-response-to-new-yorks-reproductive-health-act/

64. A Statement from the Catholic Bishops of New York State - https://archny.org/a-statement-from-the-catholic-bishops-of-new-york-state/

65. New York abortion law: Why are so many people talking about it? - https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-46994583

66. Cardinal Dolan on new state law: abortion isn't the only choice - https://nypost.com/2019/02/18/cardinal-dolan-reminds-women-abortion-isnt-only-choice-after-new-ny-law/

67. Cardinal Dolan Blasts Andrew Cuomo in New Op Ed - NY1 - https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2019/01/29/cardinal-dolan-blasts-andrew-cuomo-in-new-op-ed

68. Cardinal Dolan Says Separating Abortion from Title X Family ... - usccb - https://www.usccb.org/news/2018/cardinal-dolan-says-separating-abortion-title-x-family-planning-program-greatly-needed

69. Governor Cuomo, Cardinal Dolan continue war of words over abortion - https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/40517/governor-cuomo-cardinal-dolan-continue-war-of-words-over-abortion

70. New York Bishops Decry Equal Rights Amendment - https://www.newwaysministry.org/2024/09/03/new-york-bishops-decry-equal-rights-amendment/

71. Dolan Presses Cuomo Over Abortion - The New York Times - https://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/15/nyregion/dolan-presses-cuomo-over-abortion.html

72. Some call for Cardinal Dolan to excommunicate Cuomo for ... - https://www.catholicregister.org/archive/item/28884-some-call-for-cardinal-dolan-to-excommunicate-cuomo-for-supporting-abortion

73. Gay groups in St. Patrick's parade all right with Cardinal Dolan - https://www.ncronline.org/news/people/gay-groups-st-patricks-parade-all-right-cardinal-dolan

74. Cardinal Dolan and the St. Patrick's Day Parade - https://www.commonwealmagazine.org/cardinal-dolan-and-st-patricks-day-parade

75. NY cardinal: Parade decision is matter of gay identity vs action - https://angelusnews.com/local/la-catholics/ny-cardinal-parade-decision-is-matter-of-gay-identity-vs-action/

76. Cardinal Dolan and the St. Patrick's Day Parade - https://www.frc.org/blog/2014/09/cardinal-dolan-and-st-patricks-day-parade

77. Gay Groups in the St. Patrick's Day Parade: Cardinal Dolan's ... - https://www.americamagazine.org/all-things/2014/09/09/gay-groups-st-patricks-day-parade-cardinal-dolans-pastoral-choice/

78. NYC St. Patrick's Day Parade Finally Ends Discriminatory Ban on… - https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/nyc-st-patricks-day-parade-finally-ends-discriminatory-ban-on-lgbt-groups

79. Cardinal backs St. Patrick's Day Parade Committee as gay ban is lifted - https://www.catholicsun.org/2014/09/03/cardinal-backs-st-patricks-day-parade-committee-as-gay-ban-is-lifted/

80. Cardinal to lead St. Pat parade with 1st gay group - https://www.amarillo.com/story/lifestyle/faith/2014/09/06/cardinal-lead-st-pat-parade-1st-gay-group/13260896007/

81. Cardinal Dolan of NY leading gay pride at 2015 St. Patrick's Day ... - https://christianforumsite.com/threads/cardinal-dolan-of-ny-leading-gay-pride-at-2015-st-patricks-day-parade.40136/

82. Catholics battle over inclusion of LGBT groups in St. Patrick's Day ... - https://uscatholic.org/news_item/catholics-battle-over-inclusion-of-lgbt-groups-in-st-patricks-day-celebrations/

83. NY bishops 'extraordinarily troubled' by Gov. Hochul's decision to ... - https://www.osvnews.com/ny-bishops-extraordinarily-troubled-by-gov-hochuls-decision-to-legalize-assisted-suicide/

84. NY bishops 'extraordinarily troubled' by Gov. Hochul's decision to ... - https://www.americamagazine.org/news/2025/12/18/new-york-bishops-assisted-suicide-hochul/

85. NYS Bishops' Statement on Gov. Hochul's Plan to Sign Assisted ... - https://www.nyscatholic.org/posts/nys-bishops-statement-gov-hochuls-plan-sign-assisted-suicide-bill

86. Cardinal Dolan urges New York lawmakers: 'Prevent, don't assist ... - https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/264451/cardinal-timothy-dolan-urges-new-york-lawmakers-prevent-dont-assist-suicide-in-op-ed

87. Timothy Cardinal Dolan and the Bishops of New York State released ... - https://www.facebook.com/thegnewsroom/posts/timothy-cardinal-dolan-and-the-bishops-of-new-york-state-released-a-statement-af/1466594972137651/

88. NY bishops 'extraordinarily troubled' by Gov. Hochul's decision to ... - https://www.ncronline.org/news/ny-bishops-extraordinarily-troubled-gov-hochuls-decision-legalize-assisted-suicide

89. Statement of Cardinal Dolan and the NYS Bishops on State ... - https://archny.org/statement-of-cardinal-dolan-and-the-nys-bishops-on-state-sanctioned-suicide-bill/

90. New York Catholic bishops denounce governor's decision to ... - https://catholicvote.org/new-york-catholic-bishops-denounce-governors-decision-to-legalize-physician-assisted-suicide/

91. Cardinal Dolan slams NY assisted suicide bill that turns 'healers into ... - https://thecatholicherald.com/new-york-cardinal-opposes-state-sanctioned-assisted-suicide

92. Cardinal Dolan: New York Suicide Bill a 'Terrible Idea,' Turns ... - https://www.ncregister.com/cna/cardinal-dolan-says-cardinal-dolan-new-york-suicide-bill-turns-doctors-into-killers

93. Cardinal Timothy Dolan cuts ties with anti-abortion crusader Frank ... - https://www.ncronline.org/news/parish/cardinal-timothy-dolan-cuts-ties-anti-abortion-crusader-frank-pavone

94. Cardinal Timothy Dolan cuts ties with anti-abortion crusader Frank ... - https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/2ph7rd/cardinal_timothy_dolan_cuts_ties_with/

95. Legionaries of Christ reverse decision to honor Father Frank Pavone ... - https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2021/01/14/legionaries-christ-reverse-honor-father-frank-pavone-239725/

96. Cardinal Dolan Severs Ties With Fr. Frank Pavone's Priests For Life - https://www.patheos.com/blogs/deaconsbench/2014/12/cardinal-dolan-severs-ties-with-fr-frank-pavones-priests-for-life/

97. Cardinal cuts ties with Priests for Life, says reforms in group needed ... - https://catholicphilly.com/2014/12/news/national-news/cardinal-cuts-ties-with-priests-for-life-says-reforms-in-group-needed/

98. The Vatican's action against Frank Pavone: overdue yet unexplained - https://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/vaticans-action-against-frank-pavone-overdue-yet-unexplained/

99. A Catholic priest put an aborted fetus on the altar in an appeal for ... - https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2016/11/07/a-catholic-priest-put-an-aborted-fetus-on-the-altar-in-an-appeal-for-donald-trump/

100. [PDF] Bishop Zurek's “Never” and “Now” Pro-life Leader Frank Pavone - https://frankpavone.com/pdf/neverandnow.pdf

101. Priests for Life head says Vatican didn't tell him directly he was laicized - https://catholicreview.org/priests-for-life-head-says-vatican-didnt-tell-him-directly-he-was-laicized/

102. Cardinal Timothy Dolan cuts ties with anti-abortion crusader Frank ... - https://www.bishop-accountability.org/2014/12/cardinal-timothy-dolan-cuts-ties-with-anti-abortion-crusader-frank-pavone/

103. Bishop John P. Dolan to LGBTQ Catholics: "I wish to reaffirm your ... - https://outreach.faith/2023/07/bishop-john-p-dolan-to-lgbtq-catholics-i-wish-to-reaffirm-your-sacred-identity/

104. Father James Martin: My experience at the Synod - Outreach.faith - https://outreach.faith/2023/10/father-james-martin-my-experience-at-the-synod/

105. Pope Francis, Cardinal Dolan send greetings to Father Martin's ... - https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=59030

106. Cardinal Dolan: All Are Welcome, But. . . - New Ways Ministry - https://www.newwaysministry.org/2013/04/26/cardinal-dolan-all-are-welcome-but/

107. Cardinal Dolan endorses Fr. James Martin's new LGBT activism group - https://www.christianforums.com/threads/cardinal-dolan-endorses-fr-james-martin%25E2%2580%2599s-new-lgbt-activism-group.8253723/

108. Father James Martin Explains His Vision Regarding 'LGBT' Catholics - https://www.ncregister.com/news/father-james-martin-explains-his-vision-regarding-lgbt-catholics

109. Fr. James Martin, SJ - Timothy Cardinal Dolan greets priests from ... - https://www.facebook.com/FrJamesMartin/photos/a.10154720793656496/10154720794741496/?id=46899546495

110. Why is someone like James Martin not reprimanded? (see his recent ... - https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/141nu43/why_is_someone_like_james_martin_not_reprimanded/

111. New executive director joins outreach initiative for LGBTQ Catholics - https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2024/02/06/jesuits-outreach-james-martin-247182/

112. Father James Martin Chosen by Pope to Participate in Synod at ... - https://thetablet.org/father-james-martin-chosen-by-pope-to-participate-in-synod-at-vatican/

113. New York Priest Celebrates 'Pride Mass' Outside of Gay Monument - https://www.ncregister.com/news/pride-mass-stonewall-lgbt-catholic-church-new-york

114. mass-during-citys-pride- weekend/?utm_source=lsncathfb - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/SignoftheCrossMedia/posts/traditional-catholics-pushback-against-new-york-catholic-parish-offering-lgbt-ma/1025054396490509/

115. New York Priest Celebrates 'Pride Mass' Outside of Gay Monument ... - https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/1drd11u/new_york_priest_celebrates_pride_mass_outside_of/

116. Gay groups in St. Patrick's parade all right with Cardinal Dolan - https://www.ncronline.org/news/people/gay-groups-st-patricks-parade-all-right-cardinal-dolan

117. Catholic Gay Pride Banner Controversy - YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQMk_bME5R8

118. Gay Catholics & Catholic Lesbians – Church of St. Francis Xavier, NY - https://sites.bc.edu/here-to-stay/gay-catholics-catholic-lesbians-church-of-st-francis-xavier-ny/

119. NY cardinal: Parade decision is matter of gay identity vs action - https://angelusnews.com/local/la-catholics/ny-cardinal-parade-decision-is-matter-of-gay-identity-vs-action/

120. Video: LGBTQ Catholics celebrate Mass outside Stonewall Inn - https://religionunplugged.com/news/2019/6/28/lgbtq-catholics-celebrate-mass-outside-stonewall-inn

121. Waving Rainbow Flags at Pride Mass in NYC - Joseph Sciambra - https://josephsciambra.com/waving-rainbow-flags-at-pride-mass-in-nyc/

122. N.Y. cardinal's support for gays in parade irks conservatives - https://www.dispatch.com/story/lifestyle/faith/2014/09/05/n-y-cardinal-s-support/23587272007/

123. Cardinal Dolan's legacy at retirement: 'The ultimate happy warrior of ... - https://nypost.com/2025/12/18/us-news/cardinal-dolans-legacy-at-retirement-the-ultimate-happy-warrior-of-the-catholic-church/

124. My friend Timothy Cardinal Dolan was a gift to this city - https://www.aol.com/articles/friend-timothy-cardinal-dolan-gift-214558932.html

125. Cardinal Dolan's legacy at retirement: 'The ultimate happy warrior of ... - https://nypost.com/2025/12/18/us-news/cardinal-dolans-legacy-at-retirement-the-ultimate-happy-warrior-of-the-catholic-church/?utm_campaign=nypost&utm_medium=referral

126. Cardinal Dolan leaves behind a legacy of compassion and a ... - https://www.aol.com/articles/cardinal-dolan-leaves-behind-legacy-222132873.html

127. Radio City Rockettes lead biblical animals through the streets of NYC - https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12704049/Christmas-Radio-City-Rockettes-animals-NYC-blessed.html

128. Card. Dolan dances with the Rockettes - Tradition In Action - https://www.traditioninaction.org/RevolutionPhotos/A741-Rockettes.htm

129. Cardinal Dolan, menagerie bless Radio City's Christmas show - https://pagesix.com/2019/11/05/cardinal-dolan-menagerie-bless-radio-citys-christmas-show/

130. Timothy Cardinal Dolan added a... - Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/TimothyCardinalDolan/photos/d41d8cd9/417425626497429/

131. 39 Photos & High Res Pictures - Getty Images - https://www.gettyimages.com/editorial-images/entertainment/event/cardinal-dolan-blesses-the-christmas-spectacular-starring-the-radio-city-rockettes-living-nativity-animals/776229052

132. About - Archdiocese of New York - https://archny.org/about/

133. Archdiocese announces the closing of North Catholic and Cardinal ... - https://www.facebook.com/groups/1434456940102314/posts/2484012678480063/

134. For Catholic Schools, Crisis and Catharsis - The New York Times - https://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/18/education/18catholic.html

135. Dolan's first year tending New York Catholics - https://nypost.com/2010/04/04/dolans-first-year-tending-new-york-catholics/

136. Category Browse | Data Archive - https://www.thearda.com/data-archive/browse-categories?cid=C-B-B-C

137. [PDF] The Archdiocese Of New York: Transition From Urban Powerhouse ... - https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2141&context=gc_etds

138. Archdiocese of New York - Wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archdiocese_of_New_York

139. Pope Leo replaces New York's Cardinal Dolan in shake-up of US ... - https://wkzo.com/2025/12/18/pope-leo-replaces-new-yorks-cardinal-dolan-in-shake-up-of-us-church/

140. Ronald Hicks, the new archbishop of of New York, has a ... - NPR - https://www.npr.org/transcripts/nx-s1-5648171

141. Making All Things New Decisions Announced - https://archny.org/making-all-things-new-decisions-announced/

142. A second woman has accused ACNA Archbishop Steve Wood of ... - https://www.facebook.com/ReligionNewsSvc/posts/a-second-woman-has-accused-acna-archbishop-steve-wood-of-sexual-harassment-addin/1451740136954542/

143. Robert S. v New York Archdiocese :: 2025 - Justia Law - https://law.justia.com/cases/new-york/other-courts/2025/2025-ny-slip-op-51293-u.html

144. 5 things to know for Dec. 9: Supreme Court, Boat strikes, Clergy ... - https://www.cnn.com/2025/12/09/us/5-things-to-know-for-dec-9-supreme-court-boat-strikes-clergy-abuse-japan-earthquake-jimmy-kimmel

145. The Archdiocese of New York said it was raising $300 million as it ... - https://www.facebook.com/nytimes/posts/breaking-news-the-archdiocese-of-new-york-said-it-was-raising-300-million-as-it-/1246227940693000/

146. New York archdiocese could get priest sex abuse czar - NBC News - https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/independent-investigator-recommends-catholic-church-s-archdiocese-new-york-hire-n1060356

147. The U.S. Moves to End Gender-Related Care for Minors - https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/18/briefing/trump-gender-related-treatments-brown-shooting-investigation.html

148. AP News Summary at 8:21 a.m. EST | National News | wdrb.com - https://www.wdrb.com/news/national/ap-news-summary-at-8-21-a-m-est/article_d333733c-43b8-5f6d-9404-d30016643888.html

149. AP News Summary at 12:32 p.m. EST | National | wandtv.com - https://www.wandtv.com/news/national/ap-news-summary-at-12-32-p-m-est/article_a59f12a5-5dd4-5b70-8dce-b61b29627e08.html

150. AP News Summary at 12:20 p.m. EST - Mankato Free Press - https://www.mankatofreepress.com/news/state_national_news/ap-news-summary-at-12-20-p-m-est/article_7f76019b-7ee8-5459-8011-845754192935.html

151. Tag: Texas - NBC 5 Chicago - https://www.nbcchicago.com/tag/texas/

152. Bronx priest steps down after allegations of stealing money for drug ... - https://abc7ny.com/post/bronx-priest-steps-down-after-allegations-of-stealing-money-for-drug-fueled-lifestyle/1121155/

153. Catholic Church Faces Another Scandal - Dumas & Vaughn - https://dumasandvaughn.com/1527/

154. NY Archdiocese Responds to Allegations of Priest's Scandalous ... - https://www.ncregister.com/news/ny-archdiocese-responds-to-allegations-of-priest-s-scandalous-actions

155. Priest Accused of Using Donations for S&M Kink - https://www.courthousenews.com/priest-accused-of-using-donations-for-sm-kink/

156. Former Staten Island priest once accused of “sex-master” antics now ... - https://www.silive.com/news/2019/03/former-si-priest-once-accused-of-sex-master-antics-now-suspended-by-catholic-church.html

157. Bronx parish pastor resigns amid widely publicized scandal - https://www.ncronline.org/bronx-parish-pastor-resigns-amid-widely-publicized-scandal

158. NY Archdiocese clergy covered for priest who allegedly stole $1M - https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/2020/10/20/ny-archdiocese-covered-priest-who-allegedly-stole-1-m-investigation-finds/5868491002/

159. Another Catholic Scandal? | HuffPost Religion - https://www.huffpost.com/entry/another-catholic-scandal_b_8837572

160. Exclusive Tell-all Interview—nyc Gay Priest Embezzlement Scandal - https://www.bishop-accountability.org/news2016/03_04/2016_03_05_ChurchMilitant_ExclusiveTellall.htm

161. Disgraced ex-Bronx priest cleared of charges of using $1M in church ... - https://www.nydailynews.com/2017/10/30/disgraced-ex-bronx-priest-cleared-of-charges-of-using-1m-in-church-funds-for-sm-sex/

162. New NY archbishop — a Chicago priest, missionary, bridge builder - https://www.ncronline.org/news/new-ny-archbishop-chicago-priest-missionary-bridge-builder-reflects-pope-leos-style

163. Pope's naming of New York archbishop signals continued challenge ... - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/dec/18/pope-new-york-archbishop-trump-immigration

164. Pope replaces New York's Cardinal Timothy Dolan with little-known ... - https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/pope-replaces-yorks-cardinal-timothy-125346143.html

165. Pope Leo appoints pro-migrant archbishop of New York, signaling ... - https://www.cnn.com/2025/12/18/us/ronald-hicks-pope-archbishop-new-york-intl

166. Pope Leo Appoints Bishop Ronald Hicks to Succeed Timothy Dolan - https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/18/us/bishop-ronald-hicks-cardinal-timothy-dolan-archbishop-new-york.html

167. Pope Leo appoints pro-migrant archbishop of New York, signaling ... - https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/1ppo9rs/pope_leo_appoints_promigrant_archbishop_of_new/

168. Pope Leo replaces Cardinal Dolan with a not-so-popular Illinois ... - https://m.economictimes.com/news/international/us/pope-leo-replaces-cardinal-dolan-with-a-not-so-popular-illinois-bishop-who-is-this-new-archbishop-of-new-york/articleshow/126059308.cms

169. Pope Leo Names Pro-Migrant Archbishop for New York ... - YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aYNbpkNWiE

170. Pope replaces Dolan with Spanish-speaking bishop in New York - https://www.axios.com/2025/12/18/pope-leo-hicks-new-york-archbishop-cardinal-dolan

171. Pope replaces New York's Cardinal Dolan with pro-migrant bishop - https://www.vtcng.com/state_and_world/world_news/pope-replaces-new-yorks-cardinal-dolan-with-pro-migrant-bishop/article_ebfef005-033e-57a9-9fc0-bb72c1d2c829.html

172. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/12/archdiocese-of-ny-300-million-abuse.html

173. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/09/deification-of-charlie-kirk-blasphemy.html

174. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/01/cardinal-dolan-vs-vp-vance.html

175. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2024/02/trans-funeral-organizer-we-want-apology.html

176. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2024/02/trans-desecrate-st-patricks-cathedral.html

177. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2018/05/met-gala-heavenly-bodies-fashion-and.html

178. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2016/01/alleged-pee-drinking-gay-priest-spotted_19.html

179. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2015/12/50-shades-of-pray-priest-hunk-dolan-oh.html

180. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2014/12/rogue-priest.html

181. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2014/09/cardinal-dolan-parade-gays-my-thoughts.html

182. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2014/09/catholic-league-out.html

183. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2014/09/rainbow-beats-green.html

184. Cardinal Dolan Takes a Final Shot at Yonkers and its Hispanic Community | Yonkers Times

Pope Leo: Dolan you're out, Hicks you're in!

A New Era for the Archdiocese of New York: Pope Leo XIV Accepts Cardinal Dolan's Resignation and Appoints Bishop Ronald Hicks

On December 17, 2025, reports confirmed that Pope Leo XIV is set to accept the resignation of Cardinal Timothy Dolan as Archbishop of New York and appoint Bishop Ronald Hicks of Joliet, Illinois, as his successor. The announcement is expected as early as December 18, marking the end of Dolan's 16-year tenure leading one of the most prominent Catholic archdioceses in the United States, which serves approximately 2.8 million Catholics across nearly 300 parishes.

This transition comes at a pivotal moment for the archdiocese, which has faced significant challenges including declining attendance, parish consolidations, and the ongoing fallout from clergy abuse scandals—culminating in a major financial settlement announced just weeks ago.

 Biography of Cardinal Timothy Dolan

Timothy Michael Dolan was born on February 6, 1950, in St. Louis, Missouri, the eldest of five children. Ordained a priest in 1976, he earned a doctorate in American Church history and served in various pastoral and academic roles, including as rector of the Pontifical North American College in Rome from 1994 to 2001.

Dolan was appointed Archbishop of Milwaukee in 2002, where he navigated early waves of the clergy abuse crisis, before being named Archbishop of New York in 2009 by Pope Benedict XVI. Elevated to cardinal in 2012, Dolan became known for his charismatic media presence, humor, and outreach efforts, serving as president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops from 2010 to 2013. He turned 75 in February 2025, submitting his mandatory resignation as required by canon law.

 Biography of Bishop Ronald Hicks

Ronald Aldon Hicks, born August 4, 1967, in Harvey, Illinois, and raised in nearby South Holland, brings a Midwestern pastoral style to the role. After graduating from Quigley Preparatory Seminary, he volunteered at an orphanage in Mexico before earning degrees from Loyola University Chicago and the University of St. Mary of the Lake.

Ordained for the Archdiocese of Chicago in 1994, Hicks served in parishes, spent time in missionary work in El Salvador, and rose to vicar general under Cardinal Blase Cupich. He was named auxiliary bishop of Chicago in 2018 and installed as Bishop of Joliet in 2020. At 58, Hicks is fluent in Spanish, experienced in immigrant ministry, and noted for his collaborative leadership—qualities that align with Pope Leo XIV's own Chicago-area roots and missionary background.

 Challenges and Decline During Cardinal Dolan's Tenure

Cardinal Dolan's leadership coincided with broader trends affecting U.S. Catholicism, including declining Mass attendance, fewer vocations, and demographic shifts in urban areas. The Archdiocese of New York has seen numerous parish mergers and school closures; for instance, in 2012, 26 schools were identified as at risk. To address financial pressures, the archdiocese sold properties, reduced staff, and cut budgets.

The clergy sexual abuse crisis has been a defining challenge. Just days ago, on December 8-9, 2025, the archdiocese announced plans for a $300 million+ global settlement to resolve approximately 1,300 claims from survivors, funded through asset sales (including high-profile real estate) and operational cuts. This follows years of litigation under New York's Child Victims Act and reflects the heavy toll of past scandals on the archdiocese's resources and reputation.

While Dolan was praised for his public engagement and efforts to renew evangelization, these issues have contributed to a sense among some observers that the archdiocese has contracted in influence and vitality during his era.

 Looking Ahead

The appointment of Bishop Hicks signals Pope Leo XIV's preference for pastors with missionary experience and ties to diverse communities. As New York Catholics prepare for this change, many hope the new archbishop will bring fresh energy to revitalizing the faith in a challenging secular environment.

Sources:

- The Pillar: "Confirmed: Joliet's Bishop Hicks to NYC" (December 16, 2025)

- FOX 5 New York: Reports on Dolan's resignation and Hicks appointment (December 16-17, 2025)

- Catholic News Agency/National Catholic Register: Settlement and Hicks profile (December 2025)

- The New York Times: Archdiocese settlement announcement (December 10, 2025)

- Wikipedia and official diocesan sites for biographical details (accessed via search results, December 2025)