In an era marked by division—not only in the world but sadly among Christians—Pope Leo XIV's address at the conclusion of the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity on January 25, 2026, at the Basilica of St. Paul Outside the Walls stands as a profound reaffirmation of the Catholic Church's commitment to ecumenism. Delivered on the Feast of the Conversion of St. Paul, the Pope's homily emphasized the reality of Christian oneness, drawing directly from Scripture and the Church's longstanding teaching. He declared that Christians "share the same faith" and boldly stated, "We are one! We already are! Let us recognize it, experience it and make it visible!"
These words have sparked criticism from some traditionalist quarters, who accuse the Pope of downplaying doctrinal differences or promoting a false irenicism that ignores real divisions between Catholics and other Christian communities. Such criticisms, however, misrepresent both the Pope's intent and the authoritative teaching of the Church. Far from undermining Catholic doctrine, Pope Leo XIV's remarks echo the very foundations of Scripture, the Second Vatican Council, and prior papal magisterium. They call for a recognition of existing unity in essentials while urging fuller visible communion—a goal that has been the Church's ecumenical priority since Vatican II.
This post explores the context of the Pope's comments, explains their theological meaning, contrasts his approach with that of his predecessor Pope Francis (particularly in liturgical style and symbolic choices like the reintroduction of the morse), and demonstrates why the criticisms from traditionalists are unfounded or exaggerated. Grounded in Scripture, Church documents, and the Pope's own words, we see that his message is one of fidelity to Christ’s prayer for unity, not compromise.
The Context: The Week of Prayer for Christian Unity 2026
The Week of Prayer for Christian Unity, observed annually from January 18 to 25, culminates on the Feast of the Conversion of St. Paul. In 2026, the theme was drawn from Ephesians 4:4: “There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling.” This passage, part of St. Paul's exhortation to unity in the Church, was chosen collaboratively by the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity and representatives from other Christian traditions—in this case, prominently featuring contributions from the Armenian Apostolic Church.
Pope Leo XIV presided over Second Vespers at St. Paul Outside the Walls, joined by Cardinal Kurt Koch (Prefect of the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity), ecumenical delegations, and pilgrims. His homily reflected on Ephesians 4, noting the repeated use of "one": one body, one Spirit, one hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all (Eph 4:4-6). He highlighted how these affirmations point to a real, existing unity among baptized Christians, even amid visible divisions.
The Pope recalled his participation in an ecumenical prayer service in Iznik, Türkiye, in November 2025, commemorating the 1700th anniversary of the Council of Nicaea. There, with Orthodox Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew and other leaders, he recited the Nicene Creed together—the same creed professed by Catholics, Orthodox, and many Protestants. This act was a "profound and unforgettable testimony to our unity in Christ," he said, urging the Holy Spirit to make minds docile so that Christians might proclaim the faith "with one voice."
He also quoted his own Apostolic Letter In Unitate Fidei (November 23, 2025): “We share the same faith in the one and only God, the Father of all people; we confess together the one Lord and true Son of God, Jesus Christ, and the one Holy Spirit, who inspires us and impels us towards full unity and the common witness to the Gospel.” Concluding with the emphatic declaration: "We are one! We already are! Let us recognize it, experience it and make it visible!"
These words are not novel inventions but a restatement of Catholic ecumenical doctrine.
What Pope Leo XIV Meant: Unity in Faith Already Exists, Full Communion Is the Goal
Pope Leo XIV's assertion that "we are one" and "we have the same faith" refers to the fundamental unity bestowed by baptism and shared core beliefs, particularly in the Triune God, the divinity of Christ, and salvation through Him. This is not a denial of differences—such as papal primacy, the Filioque clause, or sacramental theology—but an acknowledgment that divisions do not erase the bond created by Christ.
Scripture supports this clearly. In John 17:20-23, Jesus prays: “I do not pray for these only, but also for those who believe in me through their word, that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me.” This prayer is for visible unity, but it presupposes an existing spiritual bond among believers.
St. Paul reinforces this in Ephesians 4:4-6, the very text central to the 2026 Week: one body, one Spirit, one hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism. Baptism incorporates into Christ, creating real unity. As the Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches: “Baptism constitutes the foundation of communion among all Christians, including those who are not yet in full communion with the Catholic Church” (CCC 1271).
The Second Vatican Council’s decree Unitatis Redintegratio (1964) affirms this explicitly: “Men who believe in Christ and have been truly baptized are in communion with the Catholic Church even though this communion is imperfect” (UR 3). The document speaks of “a certain though imperfect communion” and recognizes that other Christians “have by right a place in the Catholic Church” through baptism.
Pope Leo XIV’s words align perfectly with this. He does not claim full doctrinal agreement or sacramental sharing but recognizes the "one faith" in essentials confessed in the Nicene Creed. His call to "make it visible" echoes Vatican II’s insistence that ecumenism seeks “full visible communion,” not a superficial merger.
In Ut Unum Sint (1995), St. John Paul II wrote: “The ‘universal brotherhood’ of Christians has become a firm ecumenical conviction” (UUS 42), and he stressed shared faith as the basis for dialogue. Pope Benedict XVI, in Ut Unum Sint’s continuation, emphasized that unity is a gift already given, to be lived more fully.
Pope Leo XIV builds on this tradition, especially his motto “In Illo uno unum” (“In the One, we are one”), reflecting unity in Christ. His comments are a call to joyfully acknowledge what already binds Christians, spurring efforts toward fuller communion through prayer, dialogue, and witness.
Why Traditionalist Criticisms Are Misplaced or Exaggerated
Some traditionalist voices claim Pope Leo XIV’s words promote indifferentism or suggest all Christian denominations are equally valid, ignoring differences in doctrine or sacraments. Such accusations are unfounded.
The Pope never denied differences or suggested full communion exists now. He explicitly speaks of “full unity” as the goal, distinguishing it from the current state. His phrasing—"we are one! We already are!"—mirrors Vatican II’s language of existing yet imperfect communion. Critics who portray this as heretical overlook the nuance: spiritual/doctrinal oneness in essentials does not equate to canonical or sacramental fullness.
Traditionalists sometimes cite Pius XI’s Mortalium Animos (1928), which warned against indifferentism in ecumenism. Yet that encyclical targeted assemblies that treated all religions as equal paths; modern Catholic ecumenism, as defined by Vatican II, avoids this by affirming the unique role of the Catholic Church while recognizing elements of sanctification outside her visible boundaries (LG 8; UR 3).
Pope Leo XIV upholds this balance, as seen in his joint declaration with Patriarch Bartholomew emphasizing unity as a divine gift, not mere human agreement. His pontificate shows continuity, not rupture.
Differences from Pope Francis: Liturgical Style and the Morse
While sharing ecumenical zeal, Pope Leo XIV differs in style from Pope Francis. Francis often emphasized collegiality and simplicity, sometimes inviting other Christian leaders to join in blessings or prayers in ways highlighting shared witness.
In contrast, at events like his inaugural blessing, Pope Leo XIV offered it alone, in Latin "urbi et orbi," wearing traditional vestments including the red mozzetta and stole—signaling continuity with pre-Vatican II papal style. Reports note his use of the morse (a clasp for the cope) at the Week of Prayer Vespers, reviving a more solemn, traditional liturgical aesthetic. This choice underscores reverence for tradition while pursuing unity.
Francis sometimes reversed rituals for humility (e.g., asking crowds to bless him first). Leo XIV’s solo blessing and vestment choices affirm the Petrine office’s distinct role without diminishing ecumenical outreach. His approach complements Francis’s by blending tradition with dialogue.
Conclusion: A Papacy of Unity in Truth
Pope Leo XIV’s closing remarks for the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity are a faithful, Scripture-rooted call to recognize and live the unity Christ wills. By affirming "we are one" and "the same faith," he echoes Ephesians 4, Vatican II, and prior popes—urging visible expression without compromising doctrine. Criticisms from traditionalists often stem from misreading nuance as compromise. In reality, the Pope invites all Christians to deeper conversion, prayer, and witness, so the world may believe (Jn 17:21). As divisions persist, may we heed his words: recognize what binds us in Christ, work for fuller communion, and proclaim the Gospel together.
Sources:
- Vatican News: "Pope at Ecumenical Vespers: We are one, let's make it visible" (January 25, 2026) – https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2026-01/pope-leo-xiv-vespers-prayer-for-christian-unity-week-st-paul.html
- Vatican.va: Solemnity of the Conversion of Saint Paul - Celebration of Second Vespers (January 25, 2026) – https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/homilies/2026/documents/20260125-vespri-unita-cristiani.html
- Unitatis Redintegratio (Vatican II Decree on Ecumenism, 1964)
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, paras. 817-822, 1271
- Ut Unum Sint (St. John Paul II, 1995)
- Various reports on Pope Leo XIV’s election and pontificate (e.g., Wikipedia entry on Pope Leo XIV; Vatican News on his election as Robert Francis Prevost, May 8, 2025)
- Comparative analyses of papal styles (e.g., University of Dayton article on leadership signals, 2025)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for reading and for your comment. All comments are subject to approval. They must be free of vulgarity, ad hominem and must be relevant to the blog posting subject matter.