Altar Girls: Do They Contradict Catholicism?

The history of female participation in liturgical roles within the Catholic Church, particularly as altar servers or in roles analogous to altar servers, spans several centuries with notable shifts in practice and theology.

Early Church: In the early Christian Church, women held various roles that could be seen as precursors to altar serving. The term "deaconess" appears in historical records, with figures like Phoebe mentioned in Romans 16:1-2 by Paul. These deaconesses were involved in roles not necessarily equivalent to modern altar servers but were certainly part of the liturgical life of the church.

They assisted with the baptism of women, cared for the poor and sick, and might have had roles in other liturgical functions when appropriate. However, these roles were distinct from the ordained diaconate and did not involve serving directly at the altar in the way ordained deacons serve. Their service was distinctly different from altar servers today. This is because rites were different and there were no church buildings. However, they did help in the Liturgy perhaps with the preparation of the altar and gifts. Medieval and Later Periods: As the Church structure evolved, the role of women at the altar became more restricted. By the Middle Ages, there was a general prohibition against women serving at the altar, influenced by cultural norms of the time and theological interpretations that emphasized the male-only priesthood. Popes like Innocent IV in the 13th century explicitly forbade women from serving at the altar during Mass, a position maintained by subsequent papal decrees. Modern Restorations: - 1983 Code of Canon Law: The revised Code of Canon Law in 1983 did not explicitly prohibit women from serving at the altar, leading to some parishes unofficially allowing female altar servers. However, this was not universally accepted or practiced. - 1994 - Formal Permission: The issue was clarified when in March 1994, the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments issued a circular letter stating that both men and women could serve at the altar, although it stressed that it was still appropriate to maintain the tradition of having boys serve. This came after years of debate and practice where some dioceses in countries like the U.S. had already been allowing girls to serve. - Vatican Clarifications: While the Vatican allowed bishops to decide on the inclusion of female altar servers, it was emphasized that this did not pave the way for women's ordination to the priesthood, a stance reaffirmed by Pope John Paul II and subsequent popes. - Recent Developments: In 2021, Pope Francis modified canon law to explicitly state that all baptized persons, male or female, could be admitted to the ministries of lector and acolyte on a stable basis, further formalizing the role of women in liturgical services. This change aimed to reflect a broader understanding of the baptized person's role in the Church's liturgical life. Controversies and Discussions: The introduction of female altar servers has been both praised and criticized: - Advocates argue that it promotes equality, helps in the faith formation of young girls, and reflects the universal call to holiness and service in the Church. They see it as an extension of the baptismal priesthood where all faithful participate in the liturgical life. - Opponents often argue from tradition, suggesting that altar serving should be a step towards priesthood for boys, potentially impacting vocations. Some also express concerns about liturgical roles being defined by gender, although this view is often contested by those who argue for inclusivity based on baptismal equality.

The role of altar girls in the early Church is a topic with limited direct historical evidence, as the formalization of liturgical roles evolved over centuries. However, there are some sources and scholarly interpretations that provide insights into the participation of women in early Christian liturgies:

1. Early Christian Artifacts: Research by scholars like Ally Kateusz suggests that women had significant liturgical roles in the early Church. Artifacts such as an ivory reliquary box from around A.D. 430 and a stone sarcophagus front from the Hagia Sophia in Constantinople depict women standing at the altar, performing liturgical acts.

2. Historical Texts: Some early Church documents and writings indicate that women participated in various ministries. For example, the Didascalia Apostolorum, a third-century Christian text, mentions women deacons who assisted in baptisms and other church functions both liturgical and non-liturgical.

3. Church Fathers: While many Church Fathers, such as Pope Gelasius I, condemned the practice of women serving at the altar, there were instances where women did participate in liturgical roles, especially in convents and monastic communities.

4. Pope Francis' Reforms: In recent years, Pope Francis has made significant changes to canon law, allowing women to be permanently installed as lectors and acolytes, roles that include serving at the altar. This change reflects a broader recognition of women's contributions to the Church's liturgical life.

While the historical evidence for altar girls in the early Church is not extensive, these sources suggest that women did have roles in early Christian liturgies, and their participation has evolved over time.

Conclusion: The presence of altar girls in the Catholic Church today is a result of evolving ecclesiastical law, pastoral practice, and theological reflection on the roles of laypeople in the liturgy. While their presence at the altar today is not identical in the same capacity in the early Church, the modern role of altar servers for girls reflects a broader Church initiative towards inclusivity in liturgical ministry, while maintaining the tradition of male-only ordination to the priesthood. The debate continues to evolve, reflecting the Church's ongoing discussion about the roles of women in its sacramental life.

Claims that the presence of Altar Girls interferes with vocations to the priesthood are unfounded and not substantiated with evidence or data. These are just conjectural claims based on personal bias and a lack of understanding of theology and the liturgy concerning pastoral care. However, it is important to note that the presence of Altar Girls must not be in an attempt to satisfy identity politics or promote a sense of "equality."

The liturgy cannot be transformed into a platform for so-called "women's rights" as the secular world sees them. Girls and women looking to serve must be called by God and the Church. This is a privilege, not a right. The same applies to boys and men. No one has a right to be a server, or even a deacon, priest, bishop, monk, brother, nun, or sister. These are vocations that God directs in people. Being an Altar Girl is a service to God and His people and must never become a statement of implicit promotion of women's ordination or give a sense of quasi-priesthood. There must never be an ulterior motive.

Pastors should never feel obliged to allow female servers to appease identity politics or fanatics of women's ordination. Similarly, girls and women should not be pushed aside when genuinely seeking to serve due to misogyny, false understanding of Church tradition or any other discriminatory attitude.

Sources:

: Wikipedia : National Catholic Reporter : America Magazine

^[18] John, Paul II. (1995-06-29). Letter of Pope John Paul II to Women: The Holy See, Libreria Editrice Vaticana.

• This is word-for-word of St. John Paul II speech that he gave on the 29th of June. It should be a reliable source. It covers equality of women, apologizes for how The Church treated women in the past, and how Jesus had treated women to the highest regard and that they are equal to men.

^[19]Catechism of the Catholic Church (2nd ed.). (1997). Libreria Editrice Vaticana.

• This book was published in 1997, the first edition was published in 1992, it is the summary of all of the beliefs of the Catholic faith that anyone can read. It should be a reliable source covering the beginnings of the Catholic Church and how the different laws changed.

1. ^ Meehan, Andrew. "Acolyte." The Catholic Encyclopedia Vol. 1. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907. 14 June 2023  This article incorporates text from this source, which is in the public domain.
2. ^ "Service Book of the Orthodox Church, The (Hapgood)". SVS Press & Bookstore. Retrieved 2020-01-26.
3. ^ Fortescue, Adrian; O'Connell, J. B.; Reid, Alcuin (2009-03-29). The Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described. A&C Black. ISBN 978-0-86012-462-7.
4. ^ Alessandro Bausi, Languages and Cultures of Eastern Christianity: Ethiopian (Routledge 2017)
5. ^ Catholic Moral Theology, Fr. Jone OFMCap, Nr. 315.
6. ^ Mulieres autem servire ad altare non audeant, sed ab illius ministerio repellantur omnino
7. ^ Jump up to:^a b Benedict XIV (26 July 1755). "Allatae Sunt". Papalencyclicals.net.
8. ^ "Letter to Women (June 29, 1995) | John Paul II". www.vatican.va. Retrieved 2024-09-12.
9. ^ "Code of Canon Law - IntraText". www.vatican.va. Retrieved 2020-01-26.
10. ^ "Can. 230, § 2". www.delegumtextibus.va. Retrieved 2020-01-26.
11. ^ "Vatican Communication on Female Altar Servers". Congregation for Divine Worship. 15 March 1994. Retrieved 12 January 2021.
12. ^ Acta Apostolicae Sedis 86 (1994) pp. 541-542 (Official Latin; English translation)
13. ^ "USATODAY.com - Neb. diocese is lone U.S. holdout on allowing altar girls". USA Today.
14. ^ "Neb. diocese is lone U.S. holdout on allowing altar girls". USA Today. 22 March 2006. Archived from the original on 9 November 2017. Retrieved 2 November 2018.
15. ^ Clancy, Michael. "Phoenix diocese cathedral won't allow girl altar servers". The Arizona Republic. Archived from the original on 2 November 2018. Retrieved 2 November 2018.
16. ^ McGough, Michael (January 9, 2015). "Cardinal Burke: Serving at Mass is a 'manly' job". Los Angeles Times. Archived from the original on 2015-01-11.
17. ^ margeryeagan, "The Church has a problem with women? Really?" Archived 2016-10-02 at the Wayback Machine, Crux, January 8, 2015.
18. ^ "Letter to Women (June 29, 1995) | John Paul II". www.vatican.va. Retrieved 2024-09-11.
19. ^ "Catechism of the Catholic Church". www.usccb.org. Retrieved 2024-09-11.

The True History of Women Deacons | Charlotte Allen | First Things