Showing posts with label Diane Montagna. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Diane Montagna. Show all posts

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Did the Vatican “Kick Out” Extraordinary Form Devotees? Examining the Claims Around the 2026 Pilgrimage and Liturgical Restrictions

Did the Vatican “Kick Out” Extraordinary Form Devotees? Examining the Claims Around the 2026 Pilgrimage and Liturgical Restrictions

Recent reports and online claims that the Vatican “kicked out” Catholics devoted to the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite refer primarily to events surrounding the annual Ad Petri Sedem (also called the Summorum Pontificum) pilgrimage in October 2026. These claims reflect a real restriction on a specific group event but overstate the outcome. The Vatican did not expel such Catholics from the Church or from Vatican City as a whole. Authorities denied an organized procession and a Mass according to the 1962 Missal in St. Peter’s Basilica—after permitting a Mass there the year before. This occurs against the background of the restrictions introduced in Traditionis Custodes (2021), which remain in force under Pope Leo XIV with case-by-case permissions continuing.


 Terminology and the Extraordinary Form

The Extraordinary Form designates the Roman Rite Mass according to the 1962 Roman Missal (the final pre-conciliar edition). Pope Benedict XVI’s 2007 Summorum Pontificum described it as the “Extraordinary Form” of the one Roman Rite and expanded access to it. Advocates of this form often erroneously call it the Traditional Latin Mass (or TLM) and presume it represents the authentic, uninterrupted traditional expression of the Roman liturgy—contrasted with the post-conciliar reform. The Ordinary Form is the Mass of Paul VI (promulgated after Vatican II). Some critics erroneously call this the “Novus Ordo” (New Order), a term popularized in polemical contexts; the Church presents it as the normative expression of the Roman Rite after the Council’s liturgical directives.

Traditionis Custodes declared the liturgical books promulgated by Saints Paul VI and John Paul II the “unique expression of the lex orandi of the Roman Rite.” It restored diocesan bishops’ exclusive competence to authorize use of the 1962 Missal, generally preferred non-parish locations, prohibited new personal parishes dedicated to it, and required that groups not reject the legitimacy of the reform or Vatican II. The accompanying letter framed the measure as protecting unity.


 The October 2026 Pilgrimage Restriction

The Ad Petri Sedem pilgrimage, organized by the Coetus Internationalis Summorum Pontificum and associated groups such as Paix Liturgique, has gathered priests, religious, and lay people attached to the 1962 Missal in Rome since 2012. Participants affirm communion with the pope (“cum Petro et sub Petro”) and distinguish themselves from the Society of St. Pius X. They presume the 1962 Missal embodies the traditional Roman liturgy they seek to preserve and promote.

In October 2025, Pope Leo XIV authorized Cardinal Raymond Burke to celebrate a Pontifical Mass according to the 1962 Missal at the Altar of the Chair in St. Peter’s for the pilgrims.

For 2026, the Secretariat of State refused permission for such a Mass in the basilica. Organizers then requested (letter of 8 September) to enter in procession, pray for the pope at the Confession, and adore the Blessed Sacrament. A 30 September reply from Archbishop Paolo Rudelli (Substitute for General Affairs) stated that a favorable response was not possible. On 24 October, the procession was halted at the obelisk in St. Peter’s Square (the jurisdictional boundary). The group did not enter as a body; the Mass took place elsewhere. Organizers expressed dismay, noting prior years had allowed entry for prayer even without a Mass and that other groups had processed into the basilica.

This was a denial of an organized liturgical and processional event at a principal papal basilica, not a general ban on individual Catholics who attend the Extraordinary Form (where authorized) visiting St. Peter’s, nor an excommunication or expulsion from the Church.


 Policy Continuity and Distinction from the SSPX

Pope Leo XIV has not abrogated Traditionis Custodes. Cardinal Arthur Roche has stated that the pope will not reverse it or restore the broader permissions of Summorum Pontificum. Authorizations for the 1962 Missal in parish churches continue on a case-by-case basis at roughly similar volumes to previous years (many as two-year renewals). Some bishops have tightened local practice; others have sought or maintained permissions. Leo has indicated openness to dialogue and, in certain messages, called for generous inclusion of those attached to the older form while stressing fidelity to the post-conciliar rites.

Separately, in July 2026 the SSPX consecrated bishops without a papal mandate. The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith declared the act schismatic and excommunicated the bishops, SSPX priests, and those who formally adhere to the society. The SSPX exclusively uses the 1962 Missal and rejects substantial elements of Vatican II and the post-conciliar reforms; it is not in full communion. The Ad Petri Sedem organizers explicitly rejected any identification with the SSPX and reaffirmed their communion with the Roman Pontiff.


 What the Restriction Actually Means

The Vatican restricted a high-profile organized event by Catholics devoted to the Extraordinary Form—the form they presume is the traditional Roman liturgy—from using St. Peter’s for their 2026 pilgrimage Mass and procession, after permitting a Mass there in 2025. This is consistent with the post-Traditionis Custodes approach that treats the 1962 Missal as a limited concession rather than a freely parallel rite and seeks to avoid elevating it at the symbolic center of the Church. Catholics who attend the Extraordinary Form where permitted and remain in full communion have not been expelled. The form continues under authorization in various places.

The episode illustrates persistent disagreement over the liturgical reform: one side sees the 1962 Missal as the authentic traditional expression that should be more widely available; the other sees the post-conciliar Ordinary Form (erroneously called “Novus Ordo” by some critics) as the normative expression of the Roman Rite after Vatican II and views unrestricted parallel use of the older books as a threat to unity. Official sources offered only the brief Secretariat of State refusal; organizers reported that the previous year’s Mass had been described as “instrumentalized.”


 References


- Diane Montagna, “Vatican Bars Annual TLM Pilgrimage from Entering St. Peter’s Basilica” and “Letter Confirms Vatican Barred Annual TLM Pilgrimage from Entering St. Peter’s Basilica,” Substack (October 2026). Reports the Secretariat of State letter and the ban on the procession.

- Franca Giansoldati, “Traditionalist Pilgrims Face Vatican Ban,” Il Messaggero (23 October 2026). Contemporary Italian reporting on the organizers’ reaction and the ban.

- LifeSiteNews, “WATCH: Latin Mass pilgrimage physically prevented from visiting St. Peter’s Basilica” (24 October 2026). On-the-ground account of the procession being stopped at the obelisk.

- Catholic Culture / Catholic World News, reporting on the bar from St. Peter’s (October 2026).

- The New York Times, “Pope Leo’s Permission for Latin Mass in St. Peter’s Gives Traditionalists Hope” (25 October 2025). Context for the 2025 Mass celebrated by Cardinal Burke.

- Official text of Traditionis Custodes and the accompanying letter of Pope Francis to the bishops (16 July 2021), Vatican website / EWTN News. Primary legislative document.

- National Catholic Reporter, “Vatican liturgy chief says Pope Leo will not overturn Latin Mass restrictions” (July 2026), citing Cardinal Arthur Roche.

- EWTN / Catholic News Agency reporting on the volume of 1962 Missal permissions in 2025 remaining steady across the papal transition.

- Reuters, The Washington Post, The New York Times, and BBC coverage of the July 2026 SSPX consecrations and subsequent Vatican declaration of schism and excommunications.


These sources document the specific 2026 restriction, the continuing framework of Traditionis Custodes, and the separate SSPX developments. The Extraordinary Form has not been abolished, and its devotees who remain in communion with the pope remain members of the Catholic Church. Organized public use of what they presume to be the traditional liturgy, especially in major basilicas, continues to be subject to the restrictions established in 2021.

Monday, November 17, 2025

Diane Montagna's Echoes of Fabrication on Traditionis Custodes

The Echoes of Fabrication: Diane Montagna's Unraveling Claims on Traditionis Custodes and the Fading Mirage of Her Journalism

In the turbulent waters of contemporary Catholic discourse, where the sacred liturgy becomes a battleground for ideologies and egos, few stories have ignited as much fervor—and eventual disillusionment—as the saga surrounding Diane Montagna's explosive allegations about Pope Francis and the bishops' survey on the Extraordinary Form. On July 1, 2025, Montagna, a self-proclaimed Vatican journalist with a penchant for dramatic revelations, dropped what she billed as a bombshell on her Substack: an "exclusive" Vatican report purportedly exposing "major cracks" in the foundation of Traditionis Custodes, Pope Francis's 2021 motu proprio that imposed measured restrictions on the Missal of 1962. She claimed this document—a supposed "overall assessment" from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF)—revealed that the majority of bishops surveyed in 2020 believed changes to Summorum Pontificum (Benedict XVI's 2007 liberalization of the Missal of 1962) would "cause more harm than good." In her narrative, this was proof positive that Pope Francis had ignored episcopal consensus, fabricating a crisis to justify his decree.

The post went viral in circles favoring the Extraordinary Form, amassing thousands of views, shares, and donations to her platform. Outlets like The Remnant, LifeSiteNews, and Catholicism.org amplified her story, hailing it as vindication for those who viewed Traditionis Custodes as an assault on tradition. Montagna positioned herself as the intrepid truth-teller, the lone voice piercing the Vatican's veil of secrecy. But as the weeks turned to months, something peculiar happened: silence. Not the pregnant pause of anticipation, but the deafening void of accountability. Montagna's follow-up on July 10, 2025, merely rehashed the same partial excerpts, doubling down without new evidence. Vatican spokesmen dismissed her leaks as "very partial and incomplete," yet she offered no rebuttal, no full document, no named sources. Her claims, once a roaring inferno, flickered out like a match in the wind.

By November 2025, with Pope Leo XIV's explicit confirmation that he would not rescind Traditionis Custodes—opting instead for case-by-case dispensations—the farce was complete. Montagna's allegations, built on selective snippets and anonymous whispers, crumbled under scrutiny. What remains is not vindication, but a cautionary tale of journalistic overreach, ideological bias, and the exploitation of faithful Catholics hungry for affirmation. This is the story of how one woman's bid for clicks and clout discredited her as both a reporter and a Catholic, slandering the Holy Father and the episcopate in the process. And it is the story of how, amid the echo chamber, one voice—Sacerdotus—dared to call out the discrepancies, only to be silenced by a block on X and Substack.


 The Genesis of a Controversy: Traditionis Custodes and the 2020 Survey

To grasp the depth of Montagna's deception, one must first revisit the context of Traditionis Custodes. Issued on July 16, 2021, the motu proprio was Pope Francis's response to a growing liturgical polarization within the Church. In the accompanying letter to the world's bishops, Francis explained that a 2020 CDF survey—sent to episcopal conferences worldwide—had revealed a "situation that preoccupies and saddens me and persuades me of the need to intervene." The responses, he noted, highlighted how the Extraordinary Form was sometimes "exploited to widen the gaps, reinforce divergences, and encourage disagreements that injure the Church, block her path, and expose her to the risk of division."

This was no arbitrary edict. Summorum Pontificum had been a generous olive branch from Benedict XVI, allowing priests to celebrate the Missal of 1962 freely as an "extraordinary expression" of the Roman Rite. Yet, over 14 years, it inadvertently fostered pockets of resistance: communities where the Missal of 1962 became a symbol not just of reverence, but of rejection of Vatican II's reforms. Reports emerged of seminarians trained in the older missal viewing the Ordinary Form as deficient; of parishes divided along liturgical lines; of online forums breeding schismatic rhetoric under the guise of "tradition." The survey, compiled into a 224-page CDF report (protocol N. 03/2020-ED), synthesized these concerns without claiming unanimous negativity. It noted positive implementations in many dioceses but underscored pastoral challenges where the Missal of 1962 was weaponized against unity.

Francis's intervention restored episcopal oversight, declaring the books of the Missal of 1970 the "unique expression" of the Roman Rite's lex orandi. Bishops could permit the older form but not in parish churches without derogation, and no new groups could form around it. The goal? To heal divisions, not eradicate devotion. By 2025, under Pope Leo XIV, the document's wisdom endured: on November 13, Archbishop Miguel Maury Buendía, nuncio to Great Britain, informed the Catholic Bishops' Conference of England and Wales that Leo would not abrogate it, instead granting renewable two-year dispensations to bishops upon request. This continuity affirmed Francis's rationale—the survey did indeed reveal fractures, even if not universally catastrophic.

Enter Diane Montagna. In her July 1 piece, she claimed to possess the report's "overall assessment," alleging it contradicted Francis outright: "The majority of bishops who responded... stated that making legislative changes to Summorum Pontificum would cause more harm than good." She attached PDFs of Italian and English excerpts, protocol-stamped but conspicuously truncated. No full report. No methodology. Just enough to fuel outrage. Circles favoring the Extraordinary Form lapped it up, declaring Francis a liar who bypassed the episcopate. Montagna's Substack subscriptions surged; her X following (halted at @DianeMontagna) buzzed with adulation.

But cracks appeared almost immediately. Vatican spokesman Matteo Bruni, on July 3, called the documents "very partial and incomplete," noting Francis relied on multiple confidential reports beyond the survey. Montagna's July 10 update? More excerpts, insisting the burden of proof lay with the Vatican. Yet she produced nothing to counter Bruni's dismissal. By August, her silence was palpable—no interviews defending the leaks' integrity, no pursuit of the "other documents." Outlets like AKA Catholic began questioning her: "Montagna’s BOMBSHELL still empty." Even Rorate Caeli's Kevin Tierney noted the survey was "occasioned" but not determinative, echoing Archbishop Augustine Di Noia's 2021 clarification to National Catholic Reporter.


 The Anatomy of a Lie: Dissecting Montagna's "Evidence"

Montagna's claims weren't just incomplete; they were misleading from the outset. The leaked "assessment" she touted was a synthesis of responses from about one-third of the world's bishops (excluding Eastern-rite sees), totaling around 90 conferences. Partial leaks from 2021—long before Montagna's "scoop"—already showed nuance: over half viewed Summorum Pontificum favorably for attracting youth, but 60-70% supported tweaks for unity. Bishops like those in France and the U.S. praised its "serene" implementation, yet others decried "ideological" uses fostering "parallel Church" mentalities.

Her excerpt cherry-picked the "more harm than good" line, ignoring the report's caveats: where tensions arose, they stemmed from resistance to Vatican II, not the rite itself. The CDF's full synthesis, per Vatican insiders, balanced positives with Francis's cited concerns—gaps widened by those rejecting conciliar authority. Montagna's PDFs? Blurry scans lacking chain of custody. No whistleblower named. In an era of deepfakes and leaks, this is journalistic malpractice.

Worse, her narrative slandered the bishops. By implying they overwhelmingly backed Summorum Pontificum unchanged, she painted Francis as a tyrant overriding his flock. Yet post-2021 surveys (e.g., Catholic World Report) showed most bishops grateful for Traditionis Custodes, citing reduced divisions. In the U.S., figures like Archbishop Cordileone of San Francisco implemented it pastorally, fostering dialogue. Montagna's portrayal? A cabal of deceived prelates, gaslit by Rome. This isn't reporting; it's agitprop.

As a Catholic, her sin is graver: calumny against the Vicar of Christ. Canon 220 safeguards reputations; her unsubstantiated barbs erode trust in the magisterium. In Evangelii Gaudium, Francis warns against "spiritual worldliness"—using faith for power. Montagna's Substack, monetized on controversy, reeks of it. Donations poured in post-leak; critics like The Pillar noted her pattern of anti-Francis scoops, from synod "plots" to Amoris Laetitia "heresies." Engagement farming, not truth-seeking.


 The Cowardly Retreat: Montagna's Disappearance into the Night

By September 2025, Montagna's fervor waned. No major interviews. Her X activity? Sporadic retweets of allies favoring the Extraordinary Form, ignoring debunkings. A September 4 A Concerned Catholic post speculated her "bombshell" might "put to rest" doubts, but even there, it hinged on her unverified docs. October brought Leo XIV's first Masses—reverent, but in the Ordinary Form with Latin elements, no revival of the Missal of 1962. Advocates for the Extraordinary Form clamored for reversal; Montagna? Mute.

The block came quietly. Sacerdotus, whose critiques we'll explore, reported being barred from her X and Substack in late July—standard for dissenters in echo chambers. But her vanishing act peaked in November: as Leo XIV confirmed Traditionis Custodes's endurance via the UK nuncio, Montagna posted nothing. No mea culpa. No pivot. Just... gone. Her last substantive piece? A tangential Vatican finance gripe. The saga of the Missal of 1962, her magnum opus, evaporated.

This isn't oversight; it's evasion. True journalists chase facts; Montagna chased clout. Her silence discredits her eternally. In a Church wounded by division, she deepened it, then fled. As Proverbs 12:22 warns, "Lying lips are an abomination to the Lord." Her lips—and keyboard—proved it.


 Sacerdotus: The Lone Sentinel Against the Storm

In this maelstrom, one figure stood unyielding: Sacerdotus (@Sacerdotus on X), the pseudonymous evangelist whose blog and social media have long championed rational Catholic discourse. From July 2025 onward, Sacerdotus dissected Montagna's claims with surgical precision, the only voice systematically vetting her "evidence" amid triumphalism for the Extraordinary Form.

His July 1 critical analysis flagged the leaks' incompleteness: "Partial leaks... show a range of responses... Pope Francis’ letter states the survey revealed a ‘situation that preoccupies and saddens me,’ suggesting issues." By July 10, "Diane Montagna Rehashes the Same Lies" eviscerated her follow-up: "The protocol number... not corroborated... Bruni’s statement aligns with the possibility that the leaked sections do not represent the full scope." August's "The Unaddressed Claims of Diane Montagna" hammered her silence: "Engagement farming in the Traditionis Custodes controversy... no rebuttal to Vatican dismissal."

Sacerdotus's October pieces—"Diane Montagna & 'Traditionalists' Lied about Pope" and "Diane Montagna On World Over - Vetting Her Claims"—tied it to Leo XIV's continuity, quoting the nuncio: "Pope Leo won’t overturn restrictions." His November 14 post on Leo's stance sealed it: "Safeguarding Tradition: Pope Leo XIV’s Wise Decision."

Why the sole bulwark? Sacerdotus embodies vetting: cross-referencing leaks with magisterial texts, avoiding sensationalism. His 4,000+ X followers include diverse Catholics; blocks from figures like Montagna affirm his independence. In a field of amplifiers, he was the verifier—earning her block as badge of honor.


 The Leo XIII Legacy: Affirming Unity Over Division

Montagna's collapse gains irony under Pope Leo XIV, whose name evokes Leo XIII (1878-1903), the pontiff who navigated modernity without liturgical warfare. Contrary to claims of Leo XIII's "words regarding the Latin Mass," historical records show no direct endorsement; his era predated the Missal of 1962's codification. Yet Leo XIII championed unity in Mirae Caritatis (1902), praising Eucharistic devotion across rites—echoing Francis's Traditionis Custodes as guardian of communal prayer.

Leo XIV, elected May 2025, honors this. His inaugural Masses blended Latin with vernacular, signaling balance. On liturgy, he told La Croix (June 2025): "The Church's rites are treasures, but unity in diversity, not division in nostalgia." No "ban" on the Missal of 1962—bishops discern locally. His November 2025 UK nuncio directive? Dispensations, not rescission, affirming the survey's wisdom. Montagna's "lie" narrative? Obliterated. Leo's path: pastoral prudence, not populist reversal.

This continuity exposes her motive: drumming hits. Naive Catholics, scrolling X without vetting, bit—shares spiked 300% post-leak. But truth endures; fads fade.


 The Broader Wound: Slander, Schism, and the Call to Heal

Montagna's saga wounds deeper than one journalist. It slanders Francis, portraying him as duplicitous—a trope fueling sedevacantism. Bishops? Painted as dupes, eroding collegiality. The Church? Fractured further, when Unitatis Redintegratio demands dialogue.

Yet grace abounds. Traditionis Custodes has borne fruit: dioceses report healed parishes, youth drawn to reverent Ordinary Form celebrations. Sacerdotus's witness reminds: truth demands courage.

As Advent dawns (November 2025), let us pray for Montagna—repentance heals. For journalists: integrity over clicks. For Catholics: vet, don't vent. The liturgy lives; lies die.

In a 5000-word' reflection, this tale warns: in faith's forum, silence after storm betrays the soul. Montagna disappeared; her claims, dust. The Church marches on—united, unbroken.




 Sources


1. Montagna, Diane. "EXCLUSIVE: Official Vatican Report Exposes Major Cracks in Foundation of Traditionis Custodes." Diane Montagna's Substack, July 1, 2025. https://dianemontagna.substack.com/p/exclusive-official-vatican-report


2. Montagna, Diane. "New Evidence Confirms CDF Report, Erodes Vatican Narrative on Traditional Latin Mass Restrictions." Diane Montagna's Substack, July 10, 2025. https://dianemontagna.substack.com/p/new-evidence-confirms-cdf-report


3. "Vatican reporter finds Traditionis Custodes not based on bishops’ input, as Pope Francis claimed." LifeSiteNews, October 12, 2021. https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/vatican-reporter-finds-traditionis-custodes-not-based-on-bishops-input-as-pope-francis-claimed/


4. "The Hidden Story Behind Traditionis Custodes." Inside The Vatican, December 21, 2021. https://insidethevatican.com/magazine/the-hidden-story-behind-traditionis-custodes/


5. "Vatican correspondent releases further evidence challenging Traditionis Custodes rationale." CatholicVote, July 10, 2025. https://catholicvote.org/journalist-releases-further-evidence-challenging-traditionis-custodes-rationale


6. "UPDATE: Montagna’s BOMBSHELL still empty." AKA Catholic, July 15, 2025. https://akacatholic.com/update-montagnas-bombshell-still-empty/


7. "Vatican survey did not support Traditionis Custodes, journalist says." Catholic Culture, July 3, 2025. https://www.catholicculture.org/news/headlines/index.cfm?storyid=52523


8. "Old Mass, New Battle: Montagna’s shocking & explosive revelation on Traditionis Custodes." A Concerned Catholic, September 4, 2025. https://aconcernedcatholic.com/old-mass-new-battle-montagnas-shocking-explosive-revelation-on-traditionis-custodes/


9. "The Pastoral Lie: How Pope Francis Buried the Truth About Traditionis Custodes." Big Modernism Substack, July 2, 2025. https://bigmodernism.substack.com/p/the-pastoral-lie-how-pope-francis


10. "Vatican correspondent reports ‘major cracks’ in basis of Traditionis Custodes." CatholicVote, July 2, 2025. https://catholicvote.org/vatican-correspondent-reports-major-cracks-in-basis-of-traditionis-custodes/


11. "Decalogue Check Failed: Documents Reveal Deliberate Lies from the Vatican." The European Conservative, July 4, 2025. https://europeanconservative.com/articles/commentary/traditionis-custodes-pope-francis-lies-deceit-latin-mass-diane-montagna/


12. "Traditional Catholics Vindicated: Recent Vatican report reveals that most bishops did not want Latin Mass restrictions under ‘Traditionis Custodes’." The Remnant Newspaper, July 3, 2025. https://remnantnewspaper.com/web/index.php/headline-news-around-the-world/item/7837-traditional-catholics-vindicated-recent-vatican-report-reveals-that-most-bishops-did-not-want-latin-mass-restrictions-under-traditionis-custodes


13. "Cracks revealed in Vatican anti-Latin Mass directive." California Catholic Daily, July 3, 2025. https://www.cal-catholic.com/cracks-revealed-in-vatican-anti-latin-mass-directive/


14. "Vatican says documents on Latin Mass assessment ‘incomplete’." Archeparchy of Pittsburgh, July 2025. https://archpitt.org/vatican-says-documents-on-latin-mass-assessment-incomplete/


15. "Internal (and leaked) Vatican report questions justification for suppression of Latin Mass." ZENIT, July 3, 2025. https://zenit.org/2025/07/03/internal-and-leaked-vatican-report-questions-justification-for-suppression-of-latin-mass/


16. "Leaked Vatican Documents Undermine Francis' Stated Rationale for Suppressing Traditional Latin Mass." Novus Ordo Watch, July 3, 2025. https://novusordowatch.org/2025/07/leaked-vatican-docs-undermine-traditionis-custodes/


17. "Nuncio in Britain says pope won't overturn restrictions on old Latin Mass." USCCB, November 14, 2025. https://www.usccb.org/news/2025/nuncio-britain-says-pope-wont-overturn-restrictions-old-latin-mass


18. "Pope Leo won’t overturn restrictions on old Latin Mass, nuncio in Britain says." America Magazine, November 14, 2025. https://www.americamagazine.org/news/2025/11/14/nuncio-britain-pope-wont-overturn-latin-mass-restrictions/


19. "Leo poised to grant ‘generous’ exemptions to Traditionis custodes, UK bishops told." The Pillar, November 14, 2025. https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/leo-poised-to-grant-generous-exemptions


20. "Vatican signals continuity on Latin Mass restrictions despite rumours." The Catholic Herald, November 2025. https://thecatholicherald.com/article/vatican-signals-continuity-on-latin-mass-restrictions-despite-rumours


21. "Will Pope Leo XIV lift the Latin Mass ban?" Reddit r/Catholicism, May 14, 2025. https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/1kmxdle/will_pope_leo_xiv_lift_the_latin_mass_ban/


22. "Leo XIV: Liturgy, the Heart, and the Postmodern City." The Catholic Thing, May 14, 2025. https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2025/05/14/leo-xiv-liturgy-the-heart-and-the-postmodern-city/


23. "Pope Leo’s Latin Mass Problem." America Magazine, October 23, 2025. https://www.americamagazine.org/faith-and-reason/2025/10/22/pope-leo-latin-mass/


24. "Conservatives are cautiously hopeful that Pope Leo XIV will restore rigor to the papacy." PBS News, May 12, 2025. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/conservatives-are-cautiously-hopeful-that-pope-leo-xiv-will-restore-rigor-to-the-papacy


25. "Pope Leo XIV Will Probably Not Be Francis 2.0." The Federalist, May 9, 2025. https://thefederalist.com/2025/05/09/why-pope-leo-xiv-will-probably-not-be-francis-2-0/


26. "Pope Leo XIV & The Ancient Liturgy." Reddit r/Catholicism, May 9, 2025. https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/1kip8mi/pope_leo_xiv_the_ancient_liturgy/


27. "His Holiness Pope Leo XIV." Latin Mass Society, May 2025. https://lms.org.uk/blog/his-holiness-pope-leo-xiv


28. "Traditionalists press Pope Leo to lift restrictions on Latin mass." Church Times, June 20, 2025. https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2025/20-june/news/world/traditionalists-press-pope-leo-to-lift-restrictions-on-latin-mass


29. "Pope Leo XIV on liturgy." Reddit r/Catholicism, May 14, 2025. https://www.reddit.com/r/Catholicism/comments/1kmc1wx/pope_leo_xiv_on_liturgy/


30. "Pope Leo’s Permission for Latin Mass in St. Peter’s Gives Traditionalists Hope." The New York Times, October 25, 2025. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/25/world/europe/pope-leo-latin-mass-traditionalists.html


31. Sacerdotus. "Critical Analysis of Diane Montagna's Article and Claims Regarding Traditionis Custodes." Sacerdotus.com, July 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/07/critical-analysis-of-diane-montagnas.html


32. Sacerdotus. "Diane Montagna Rehashes the Same Lies." Sacerdotus.com, July 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/07/diane-montagna-rehashes-same-lies.html


33. Sacerdotus. "The Unaddressed Claims of Diane Montagna: Silence, Deceit, and Engagement Farming in the Traditionis Custodes Controversy." Sacerdotus.com, August 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/08/the-unaddressed-claims-of-diane.html


34. Sacerdotus. "Diane Montagna & 'Traditionalists' Lied about Pope." Sacerdotus.com, October 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/07/diane-montagna-traditionalists-lied.html


35. Sacerdotus. "Diane Montagna On World Over - Vetting Her Claims." Sacerdotus.com, October 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/07/diane-montagna-on-world-over-vetting.html


36. Sacerdotus. "Pope Leo XIV Will Not Rescind Traditionis Custodes." Sacerdotus.com, November 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/11/pope-leo-xiv-will-not-rescind.html


37. Sacerdotus. "The Fourth Anniversary of Traditionis Custodes: Why It was Needed." Sacerdotus.com, July 16, 2025. https://www.sacerdotus.com/2025/07/the-fourth-anniversary-of-traditionis.html


38. Pope Francis. Traditionis Custodes and Accompanying Letter. Vatican, July 16, 2021. (Full text available via Vatican.va)


39. Pope Leo XIII. Mirae Caritatis. Vatican, May 28, 1902. (On Eucharistic unity; no direct reference to the Missal of 1962, as it predates its codification.)


40. Various X Posts by @Sacerdotus on Diane Montagna and Traditionis Custodes (July-November 2025), e.g., Post ID: 1968849287627882560: "Pope Leo XIV also confirmed what Pope Francis stated... Diane Montagna... confirmed to have lied." https://x.com/Sacerdotus/status/1968849287627882560

Thursday, September 25, 2025

Is the 'Latin Mass' Being Restricted? A Crackdown?

The Latin Mass: Unity in Diversity, Not Restriction

The claim that the Catholic Church is restricting or cracking down on the Latin Mass has gained traction in certain circles, particularly among those who prefer the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite. This narrative, often amplified by traditionalist commentators, paints a picture of a Church intent on suppressing a cherished liturgical tradition. 

However, this perspective oversimplifies a complex issue and fails to account for the broader context of liturgical unity, episcopal authority, and the Church’s mission to foster communion. Recent actions by bishops like Michael Martin of Charlotte and Daniel Garcia of Monterey, as well as statements from Pope Leo XIV, demonstrate not a crackdown but a careful effort to ensure the Mass—whether in its Ordinary or Extraordinary Form—serves its purpose as a unifying act of worship. Moreover, concerns about the Extraordinary Form being used to promote political agendas, particularly right-wing ideologies, highlight the need for pastoral oversight. This post will refute the claim of a crackdown, clarify the Church’s teaching on the unity of the Latin Mass, affirm the authority of bishops to regulate liturgy, and address the misuse of the Extraordinary Form for ideological purposes, all while emphasizing that the Mass, in any form, is inherently traditional.


 The Unity of the Latin Mass: One Rite, Two Expressions

At the heart of the discussion is a fundamental truth reaffirmed by Pope Leo XIV: there is only one Latin Mass, expressed in two forms—the Ordinary Form and the Extraordinary Form. This understanding, rooted in the Church’s liturgical theology, counters the notion of a division between two competing rites. The Ordinary Form, promulgated by Pope Paul VI following the Second Vatican Council, and the Extraordinary Form, based on the 1962 Roman Missal, are not separate liturgies but complementary expressions of the same Roman Rite. Pope Leo XIV has reiterated this principle, emphasizing that both forms share the same theological substance: the celebration of Christ’s sacrifice and the unity of the Church in worship.

The claim of a “crackdown” often stems from a misinterpretation of actions taken to regulate the Extraordinary Form, particularly following Pope Francis’ 2021 motu proprio Traditionis Custodes. Critics argue that this document and subsequent episcopal decisions aim to suppress the Extraordinary Form. However, this view overlooks the Church’s intent to address divisions and ensure that all celebrations of the Mass reflect the unity of the Roman Rite. Pope Francis expressed concern that the Extraordinary Form was, in some cases, being used to reject the liturgical reforms of Vatican II, creating a sense of division rather than communion. Pope Leo XIV, while adopting a gentler tone, has continued to uphold this principle, emphasizing that the Church’s liturgy must foster harmony, not discord.

The idea of a single Latin Mass with two expressions is not new. Pope Benedict XVI, in his 2007 motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, described the Ordinary and Extraordinary Forms as “two usages of the one Roman Rite.” This framework rejects the notion that one form is superior or more “traditional” than the other. Both forms, when celebrated with reverence, express the same mystery of faith. The Ordinary Form, with its use of the vernacular and simplified structure, makes the liturgy more accessible to many, while the Extraordinary Form, with its Latin prayers and intricate rituals, appeals to those drawn to its historical depth. By affirming this unity, Pope Leo XIV has clarified that the Church is not restricting the Latin Mass but ensuring that its expressions serve the common good of the faithful.


 Episcopal Authority and Liturgical Regulation

Bishops, as successors of the apostles, hold the authority to regulate the liturgy within their dioceses. This responsibility, rooted in canon law and reaffirmed by Traditionis Custodes, ensures that the celebration of the Mass aligns with the Church’s mission to promote unity. Recent cases involving Bishop Michael Martin of Charlotte and Bishop Daniel Garcia of Monterey illustrate how bishops exercise this authority, not to suppress the Extraordinary Form but to integrate it into the broader life of the Church.

In the Diocese of Charlotte, Bishop Michael Martin initially proposed restrictions on the Extraordinary Form in 2025, prompting concern among some traditionalist communities. However, following backlash, he delayed these measures, stating that the diocese would abide by any future Vatican directives. This decision reflects a pastoral approach, balancing the needs of those attached to the Extraordinary Form with the diocese’s commitment to liturgical unity. Rather than a blanket ban, Bishop Martin designated a specific chapel for the celebration of the Extraordinary Form, ensuring its availability while adhering to Vatican guidelines. This move demonstrates that regulation is not synonymous with restriction; it is about ordering worship in a way that serves all the faithful.

Similarly, Bishop Daniel Garcia, in one of his final acts as Bishop of Monterey, issued a letter in September 2025 terminating the Extraordinary Form at a parish where it was celebrated by Father Stephen Akers. Garcia’s decision was grounded in his desire to strengthen unity within the diocese, citing the small number of attendees at the Extraordinary Form and the need for the pastor to focus on the entire parish community. He referenced Traditionis Custodes and Pope Leo XIV’s call for harmony, urging the faithful to participate in the Ordinary Form as a sign of communion. Critics framed this as a “crackdown,” but Garcia’s action was a legitimate exercise of episcopal authority, prioritizing the pastoral needs of the diocese over the preferences of a small group.

These cases highlight a key point: bishops are tasked with discerning how best to celebrate the liturgy in their local contexts. The Church does not operate on a one-size-fits-all model; what works in one diocese may not suit another. By regulating the Extraordinary Form, bishops like Martin and Garcia are not attacking tradition but ensuring that the liturgy remains a source of unity rather than division. This authority is not new but flows from the Church’s structure, where bishops, in communion with the Pope, shepherd their flocks.


 The Extraordinary Form and Ideological Misuse

One of the most significant concerns raised by Traditionis Custodes and echoed in recent discussions is the misuse of the Extraordinary Form to promote political and ideological agendas, particularly those associated with right-wing ideologies. While the Extraordinary Form itself is a legitimate and beautiful expression of the Church’s liturgy, some within the traditionalist movement have used it as a platform to advance views that are at odds with the Gospel. This issue, more than any other, underscores the need for careful oversight by bishops and the Vatican.

Traditionalist communities, while often devout, have at times aligned themselves with political movements that emphasize nationalism, anti-immigrant sentiment, or rejection of modern Church teachings. For example, some traditionalist groups have been vocal in their opposition to Pope Francis’ emphasis on social justice, environmental stewardship, and openness to marginalized groups. These stances, which can veer into right-wing ideologies, are not inherent to the Extraordinary Form but have been associated with it in certain contexts. Pope Francis noted in 2021 that some adherents of the Extraordinary Form rejected the Second Vatican Council, claiming it betrayed the “true Church.” This rejection can foster a sense of alienation from the broader Catholic community, creating parallel communities that prioritize ideological purity over ecclesial unity.

The Extraordinary Form, with its rich symbolism and historical continuity, can be a powerful tool for evangelization, as seen in events like the traditionalist pilgrimage from Paris to Chartres, which drew 20,000 young people in June 2025. However, when it becomes a rallying point for political agendas, it risks losing its spiritual focus. Bishops, in their role as guardians of the liturgy, must ensure that the Mass—whether Ordinary or Extraordinary—remains a celebration of Christ’s sacrifice, not a vehicle for ideological battles. The actions of bishops like Martin and Garcia reflect this pastoral concern, seeking to curb divisions that arise when the liturgy is co-opted for non-spiritual purposes.


 The Mass: Traditional by Default

A critical point often overlooked in the debate is that the Mass, in both its Ordinary and Extraordinary Forms, is inherently traditional. The term “traditional” does not belong exclusively to the Extraordinary Form; it applies to the entire Roman Rite, which has evolved over centuries while retaining its core elements. The Ordinary Form, far from being a modernist invention, is rooted in the same sacrificial theology as the Extraordinary Form. Both forms celebrate the Eucharist, proclaim the Word of God, and unite the faithful in worship. To claim that only the Extraordinary Form is “traditional” is to misunderstand the nature of tradition in the Church.

Tradition, in the Catholic sense, is not static but living. The Second Vatican Council, in its constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium, called for a reform of the liturgy to make it more accessible while preserving its sacred character. The Ordinary Form, with its use of the vernacular and simplified structure, fulfills this vision while maintaining continuity with the Church’s liturgical heritage. The Extraordinary Form, while preserving older rituals, is not a frozen relic but a living expression of the same faith. Both forms, when celebrated with reverence, reflect the Church’s tradition of adapting to the needs of the faithful while safeguarding the deposit of faith.

The narrative of a “crackdown” on the Extraordinary Form often portrays the Ordinary Form as less traditional or even deficient. This view is not only divisive but theologically flawed. The Mass, regardless of its form, is the source and summit of the Christian life, as Vatican II taught. Whether in Latin or the vernacular, with Gregorian chant or contemporary hymns, the Mass remains the same sacrifice of Christ. By emphasizing this truth, Pope Leo XIV and bishops like Martin and Garcia are not restricting tradition but upholding it in its fullest sense.


 Refuting the Crackdown Narrative

Armchair pundits and pretend muckrakers like Diana Montagna are quick to label a bishop's actions as a "crackdown," but this is just bearing false witness.  The claim of a crackdown on the Latin Mass does not hold up under scrutiny. Actions like those of Bishop Martin and Bishop Garcia are not about suppressing the Extraordinary Form but about ensuring that it serves the Church’s mission of unity. The Church has not banned the Extraordinary Form; rather, it has placed its celebration under the authority of bishops, who are best positioned to assess the needs of their dioceses. Pope Leo XIV’s approach, while more conciliatory than his predecessor’s, continues to prioritize this unity, as seen in his exemption for the Diocese of San Angelo, where the Extraordinary Form continues to thrive under specific conditions.

Moreover, the Church’s history shows that liturgical regulation is not new. In 1984, Pope John Paul II allowed limited use of the Extraordinary Form under strict conditions, and Pope Benedict XVI expanded access in 2007 while still affirming episcopal oversight. Traditionis Custodes and subsequent actions build on this tradition of balancing freedom with responsibility. The leaked Vatican documents from 2025, which suggested that a majority of bishops viewed the Extraordinary Form favorably, do not undermine this approach; they highlight the complexity of liturgical governance and the need for dialogue, not division.

The Extraordinary Form remains available in many dioceses, often with Vatican exemptions or episcopal approval. For example, in San Angelo, Bishop Michael Sis successfully petitioned for an exemption, allowing the Extraordinary Form to continue at St. Margaret of Scotland Parish. This case, far from evidencing a crackdown, shows the Church’s flexibility in accommodating the needs of the faithful while maintaining oversight. Similarly, the delay in Charlotte reflects a willingness to listen and adapt, not a rigid suppression of the liturgy.


 Conclusion

The narrative of a crackdown on the Latin Mass misrepresents the Church’s efforts to foster unity and regulate the liturgy responsibly. Pope Leo XIV’s affirmation of one Latin Mass with two expressions—the Ordinary and Extraordinary Forms—underscores the Church’s commitment to its liturgical heritage. Bishops like Michael Martin and Daniel Garcia, in exercising their authority, are not restricting tradition but ensuring that the Mass serves its purpose as a unifying act of worship. The misuse of the Extraordinary Form to promote right-wing ideologies highlights the need for such oversight, as the liturgy must remain a spiritual, not political, act. Above all, the Mass, in any form, is traditional by default, rooted in the unchanging sacrifice of Christ. By understanding these truths, Catholics can move beyond divisive narratives and embrace the richness of the Roman Rite in all its expressions.


References and Sources  

- Catholic News Agency, “Bishop cancels Latin Mass in California parish to bring about ‘unity’,” September 23, 2025  [](https://catholicnewsagency.com/news/266731/bishop-cancels-latin-mass-in-california-parish-to-bring-about-unity)

- National Catholic Register, “Charlotte Bishop Delays Traditional Latin Mass Restrictions After Backlash,” June 3, 2025  [](https://www.ncregister.com/news/charlotte-bishop-delays-traditional-latin-mass-restrictions-after-backlash)

- Catholic News Agency, “Cardinal Raymond Burke says he asked Pope Leo XIV to lift Latin Mass restrictions,” June 16, 2025  [](https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/264773/cardinal-burke-asks-pope-leo-to-lift-latin-mass-restrictions)

- The Catholic Thing, “Pope Leo’s early challenge: What to do about Pope Francis’ Latin Mass restrictions,” June 5, 2025  [](https://www.thecatholicthing.org/2025/06/05/pope-leos-early-challenge-what-to-do-about-pope-francis-latin-mass-restrictions/)

- Concho Valley Homepage, “Exclusive from Rome: Pope Leo XIV issues exemption to San Angelo Diocese,” July 17, 2025  [](https://www.conchovalleyhomepage.com/news/exclusive-from-rome-pope-leo-xiv-issues-exemption-to-san-angelo-diocese/)

- Catholic Review, “Traditionalist Catholics see evangelization potential of Latin Mass,” June 20, 2025  [](https://catholicreview.org/traditionalist-catholics-see-evangelization-potential-of-latin-mass/)

- Catholic News Agency, “Diocese of Charlotte will restrict Latin Mass in line with Pope Francis’ directive,” May 24, 2025  [](https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/264333/diocese-of-charlotte-will-restrict-latin-mass-in-line-with-pope-francis-directive)

- ZENIT, “Will Leo XIV Remove Restrictions on The Traditional Mass? A Cardinal Has Asked Him to Do So,” June 30, 2025  [](https://zenit.org/2025/06/30/will-leo-xiv-remove-restrictions-on-the-traditional-mass-a-cardinal-has-asked-him-to-do-so-this-is-what-he-said/)

- The New York Times, “Pope Francis Restricts Use of Old Latin Mass, in a Blow to Conservatives,” July 16, 2021  [](https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/16/world/europe/pope-francis-old-latin-mass.html)

- AP News, “Pope intervenes again to restrict celebration of Latin Mass,” February 21, 2023  [](https://apnews.com/article/pope-francis-vatican-city-religion-13fb8d27e538fc0aafec26a5087d387e)

- National Catholic Reporter, “Pope Francis approves further restrictions on Latin Mass to ensure adherence to Vatican II,” December 17, 2021  [](https://www.ncronline.org/news/vatican/pope-francis-approves-further-clarifications-latin-mass-restrictions-ensure-adherence)

- National Catholic Reporter, “The traditional Latin Mass is not the problem with traditionalist communities,” August 18, 2021  [](https://www.ncronline.org/news/opinion/traditional-latin-mass-not-problem-traditionalist-communities)

- AP News, “Vatican says leaked documents were only part of information Pope Francis used to restrict Latin Mass,” July 2, 2025  [](https://apnews.com/article/vatican-latin-mass-pope-leo-francis-catholic-5c15ea6c49b255a7d98cde9276a46acd)

- Catholic News Agency, “Vatican downplays leaked documents on Latin Mass,” July 3, 2025  [](https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/265151/vatican-downplays-leaked-documents-on-latin-mass)


 

Monday, August 18, 2025

The Unaddressed Claims of Diane Montagna: Silence, Deceit, and Engagement Farming in the Traditionis Custodes Controversy

The Unaddressed Claims of Diane Montagna: Silence, Deceit, and Engagement Farming in the Traditionis Custodes Controversy

In July 2021, Pope Francis issued the motu proprio Traditionis Custodes, a document that significantly restricted the celebration of the Extraordinary Form, reversing the broader permissions granted by Pope Benedict XVI’s 2007 apostolic letter Summorum Pontificum. The Vatican cited a 2020 survey of bishops, conducted by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), as a key factor in this decision, with Pope Francis stating that the survey revealed a situation that “preoccupies and saddens me, and persuades me of the need to intervene.” 

This move sparked intense debate, particularly among traditionalist Catholics who felt the decision undermined their liturgical preferences. Among the voices amplifying this controversy was Diane Montagna, a senior American journalist and Vatican correspondent, whose reporting in 2021 and 2025 alleged that the Vatican misrepresented the survey’s findings to justify Traditionis Custodes. However, Montagna’s claims, which stirred significant attention, have since been met with silence—both from her and her supporters—raising questions about their validity, her motives, and the dynamics of engagement farming within traditionalist Catholic circles.

This blog post examines Montagna’s allegations, her subsequent silence on the matter, and the implications of her approach. It argues that her selective reporting, failure to address counterevidence, and lack of follow-up suggest a pattern of deceit aimed at exploiting the emotions of traditionalist Catholics for engagement and influence, rather than a commitment to truth. By analyzing her claims, the Vatican’s response, and the broader context of traditionalist media, this post will highlight how Montagna’s narrative fits into a larger trend of sensationalism that prioritizes gossip over reality.


 The Context: Traditionis Custodes and the 2020 Bishops’ Survey

To understand Montagna’s claims, we must first consider the backdrop of Traditionis Custodes. In 2007, Pope Benedict XVI’s Summorum Pontificum liberalized access to the Extraordinary Form, allowing priests to celebrate it without special permission and recognizing it as the “Extraordinary Form” of the Roman Rite. This move aimed to foster unity by accommodating traditionalist Catholics while affirming the Ordinary Form (the post-Vatican II Mass) as the normative liturgy. However, by 2020, concerns arose in the Vatican about the Extraordinary Form’s role in fostering division, particularly among groups rejecting the Second Vatican Council’s liturgical reforms.

In response, Pope Francis commissioned the CDF to survey bishops worldwide on the implementation of Summorum Pontificum. The survey, conducted between spring 2020 and January 2021, asked bishops about the Extraordinary Form’s impact in their dioceses, including its pastoral necessity, influence on seminaries, and any associated challenges. The CDF compiled a 224-page report, which included a detailed analysis and a summary with an “Overall Assessment” (Giudizio Complessivo). Pope Francis cited this survey in his July 2021 letter accompanying Traditionis Custodes, noting that it revealed issues requiring intervention, such as the use of the Extraordinary Form to “widen gaps, reinforce divergences, and encourage disagreements that injure the Church.”

Enter Diane Montagna. In July 2021, and more prominently in July 2025, Montagna published articles on her Substack claiming to have obtained parts of the CDF’s report, specifically the Overall Assessment and a collection of bishops’ quotations. She argued that the survey showed widespread bishop satisfaction with Summorum Pontificum, contradicting the Vatican’s rationale for Traditionis Custodes. Her July 1, 2025, article, titled “EXCLUSIVE: Official Vatican Report Exposes Major Cracks in Foundation of Traditionis Custodes,” alleged that the Vatican misrepresented the survey to justify restricting the Extraordinary Form, with some commentators even accusing Pope Francis of lying. Her follow-up on July 10, 2025, doubled down, citing additional excerpts and challenging Vatican spokesman Matteo Bruni’s dismissal of her documents as “partial and incomplete.” These claims gained traction, with her initial X post garnering over 1 million views.


 Montagna’s Claims: A Closer Look

Montagna’s central assertion is that the CDF’s 2020 survey showed that most bishops who responded were satisfied with Summorum Pontificum and opposed changes to it, suggesting that Traditionis Custodes was based on a false premise. She cited the Overall Assessment, which reportedly stated that “the majority of bishops who responded to the questionnaire, and who have generously and intelligently implemented the MP Summorum Pontificum, ultimately express satisfaction with it,” and that altering it “would cause more harm than good.” She also highlighted positive comments, such as those from Archbishop Allen Vigneron, who praised Summorum Pontificum for fostering ecclesial peace, and noted the Extraordinary Form’s appeal to younger Catholics and converts.

However, Montagna’s reporting has significant flaws. First, she only published excerpts of the report’s second part (the summary), not the full 224-page document, which includes detailed, continent-by-continent analysis. This selective presentation raises concerns about cherry-picking data to support her narrative. For instance, a leaked survey from France, not addressed by Montagna, reportedly highlighted the Extraordinary Form’s negative impact on Church unity in some dioceses, aligning with Pope Francis’s stated concerns. Second, her claim that the Vatican misrepresented the survey assumes that Pope Francis asserted a majority of bishops demanded restrictions, which he did not. His letter emphasized a “situation” requiring intervention, not a universal consensus.

Moreover, the Vatican’s response, via Matteo Bruni, undermines Montagna’s narrative. On July 3, 2025, Bruni described her documents as “a very partial and incomplete reconstruction of the decision-making process,” suggesting that Pope Francis relied on additional, confidential reports. Montagna dismissed this, arguing that Traditionis Custodes only cited the bishops’ survey, but she failed to provide evidence that these other reports did not exist or were irrelevant. The Vatican’s silence on the documents’ authenticity further weakens her case, as does the fact that the CDF’s Fourth Section, which compiled the report, was formerly the Ecclesia Dei Commission, tasked with overseeing Summorum Pontificum. This group had a vested interest in presenting the Extraordinary Form favorably, potentially skewing the Overall Assessment.


 The Silence: Montagna’s Failure to Follow Up

Since her July 2025 articles, Montagna has not revisited her claims about the CDF survey or addressed the Vatican’s counterarguments. Her Substack and X posts have shifted focus to other topics, such as Pope Leo XIV’s message on the Hiroshima anniversary or critiques of Amoris Laetitia. This silence is striking, given the gravity of her accusations. If her documents truly exposed Vatican deceit, one would expect ongoing advocacy, especially as traditionalist Catholics continue to debate Traditionis Custodes. Instead, her lack of updates suggests either an inability to substantiate her claims further or a deliberate choice to move on after generating significant attention.

This silence aligns with a pattern of engagement farming, where sensational claims are made to capture attention but not sustained with rigorous follow-through. Montagna’s initial posts were amplified by prominent traditionalist figures like Dr. Peter Kwasniewski and Damian Thompson, who called her report a “BOMBSHELL” and accused Pope Francis of lying. Yet, these supporters have also largely dropped the issue, with no significant push for the Vatican to release the full survey or for Pope Leo XIV to retract Traditionis Custodes. This collective forgetting suggests that the controversy was less about truth and more about rallying traditionalist Catholics against a perceived Vatican agenda.


 Engagement Farming and the Traditionalist Audience

Montagna’s approach taps into a broader phenomenon within traditionalist Catholic media: engagement farming. Traditionalist Catholics, often skeptical of Vatican II and modern Church leadership, are a receptive audience for narratives of betrayal or conspiracy. Montagna’s claims about Traditionis Custodes—framed as exposing Vatican lies—resonate with this group’s distrust of Pope Francis, whom some view as hostile to tradition. By presenting selective evidence and framing it as a “BOMBSHELL,” Montagna generated significant online traction, with her X post reaching 1 million views. This aligns with the dynamics of social media, where provocative content drives clicks, shares, and subscriptions, even if it lacks full substantiation.

The traditionalist Catholic community’s appetite for such narratives often prioritizes gossip over facts. Comments on platforms like CatholicVote.org reveal a tendency to embrace Montagna’s claims without scrutiny, with users decrying Pope Francis as a “heretic” or celebrating the supposed exposure of Vatican deceit. This reaction reflects a confirmation bias, where traditionalists seek validation of their belief that the Vatican is suppressing the Extraordinary Form unjustly. Montagna’s failure to provide the full report or address counterevidence, such as the French survey, feeds this bias, as her audience is less likely to demand rigorous proof and more likely to accept her narrative as truth.


 The Role of Deceit and Selective Reporting

While Montagna’s supporters view her as a truth-teller, critics argue her reporting is misleading. A critical analysis on Sacerdotus.com accuses her of “deliberate falsehoods” through selective use of evidence and omission of countervailing data, such as the French survey’s findings on Extraordinary Form-related divisions. The site notes that her reliance on the Ecclesia Dei Commission’s summary, which may have been biased toward the Extraordinary Form, undermines her claim of exposing Vatican lies. Furthermore, her dismissal of Bruni’s statement about additional reports, without evidence to disprove their existence, suggests a predetermined narrative rather than objective journalism.

Montagna’s silence since July 2025 reinforces this critique. If her claims were as groundbreaking as she asserted, one would expect continued pressure on the Vatican to release the full survey or a response to Bruni’s statement. Instead, her shift to other topics suggests that the Traditionis Custodes controversy served as a vehicle for attention rather than a genuine pursuit of truth. This pattern is evident in her earlier 2021 reporting, which made similar claims but lacked follow-through, indicating a recurring strategy of dropping sensational stories without resolution.


 The Broader Implications

Montagna’s case highlights a troubling trend in Catholic media: the exploitation of liturgical and doctrinal disputes to fuel division and engagement. Traditionalist Catholics, feeling marginalized by Traditionis Custodes, are particularly vulnerable to narratives that cast the Vatican as the villain. While some of Montagna’s points—such as the survey’s positive comments about the Extraordinary Form—may have merit, her selective presentation and failure to engage with counterevidence undermine her credibility. Her silence since July 2025 further suggests that her goal was not to foster dialogue or reform but to capitalize on traditionalist outrage.

This dynamic has broader implications for the Church. The polarization between traditionalists and those supportive of Vatican II’s reforms is exacerbated by such reporting, which thrives on division rather than unity. Pope Francis’s stated goal in Traditionis Custodes was to address liturgical disunity, yet sensationalist narratives like Montagna’s deepen the divide, portraying traditionalists as victims of a deceitful Vatican. The lack of follow-up from Montagna and her supporters also points to a missed opportunity for constructive dialogue, such as advocating for the full survey’s release or engaging with Pope Leo XIV’s administration to revisit the issue.


 Conclusion

Diane Montagna’s claims about Pope Francis misrepresenting the 2020 bishops’ survey in Traditionis Custodes sparked significant controversy, but her silence since July 2025 reveals the fragility of her narrative. By selectively presenting evidence, ignoring counterpoints like the French survey, and failing to sustain her critique, Montagna appears to have engaged in deceitful reporting aimed at farming engagement from traditionalist Catholics. Her audience, prone to embracing gossip over facts, amplified her claims without demanding rigor, perpetuating a cycle of sensationalism. This case underscores the need for Catholics to approach such controversies with discernment, prioritizing truth over divisive narratives. As the Church navigates the legacy of Traditionis Custodes, honest dialogue, not engagement farming, is essential for healing and unity.


 


Sources:

- Sacerdotus: 

Sacerdotus: Critical Analysis of Diane Montagna's Article and Claims Regarding Traditionis Custodes

Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna Rehashes the Same Lies

Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna & 'Traditionalists' Lied about Pope Francis

Sacerdotus: Diana Montagna Blocks Sacerdotus on X After Refutation of Her Claims on Pope Francis: A Sign of Weak Journalism?

Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna On World Over - Vetting Her Claims

- CatholicVote.org: Vatican correspondent releases further evidence

- California Catholic Daily: Cracks revealed in Vatican anti-Latin Mass directive

- AKACatholic.com: Diane Montagna’s Empty BOMBSHELL UPDATE: Montagna’s BOMBSHELL still empty -

- CatholicVote.org: Vatican correspondent reports ‘major cracks’

- Anthony Esolen on X, July 2, 2025

- Dr. Peter Kwasniewski on X, July 10, 2025


 

Thursday, July 17, 2025

The Fourth Anniversary of Traditionis Custodes: Why It was Needed

The Fourth Anniversary of Traditionis Custodes: A Reflection on Unity and Division in the Church I consider myself a traditionalist. I love the liturgy, the vestments, the rich culture of the Church, and Latin as the official language of the Roman Rite. Perhaps you, reading this or having read my other content, may think I am not being honest about being a traditionalist and may "hate" or dislike the Extraordinary Form.

This is far from the truth and reality. Just see the X post below this paragraph to see what I posted in 2022. I serve at both the Extraordinary Form and the Ordinary Form of the Mass with reverence and devotion. But I must be objective and call a spade a spade. I will not worship a liturgical rite nor place it—or my personal preferences—above the unity and mission of the Catholic Church. As we mark the fourth anniversary of Pope Francis’ motu proprio Traditionis Custodes on July 16, 2025, it’s an opportune moment to reflect on why this document was issued, the ideologies that prompted its necessity, and the ongoing challenges within certain traditionalist circles. This reflection also addresses recent claims, such as those by Vatican journalist Diane Montagna, and why it is unlikely that Pope Leo XIV will rescind this decree.


The Context and Necessity of Traditionis Custodes On July 16, 2021, Pope Francis issued Traditionis Custodes (Apostolic Letter issued “Motu proprio” by the Supreme Pontiff Francis “Traditionis custodes” on the use of the Roman Liturgy prior to the Reform of 1970, 16 July 2021 | Francis), a motu proprio that significantly restricted the celebration of the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite, reversing the broader permissions granted by Pope Benedict XVI’s 2007 motu proprio Summorum Pontificum. The document was accompanied by a letter to the world’s bishops, explaining the reasons behind this decision. Pope Francis cited the need to foster unity within the Church, expressing concern that the Extraordinary Form was being used in ways that undermined the liturgical reforms of the Second Vatican Council and, by extension, the unity of the Church itself.

The necessity of Traditionis Custodes arose from a complex situation. Pope Francis acted after a 2020 survey conducted by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (now Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith), which gathered feedback from bishops worldwide about the implementation of Summorum Pontificum. Other documents and information were used as well, according to Vatican Spokesman Matteo Bruni. The responses revealed a troubling reality: in some communities, the celebration of the Extraordinary Form was not merely a matter of liturgical preference but had become a rallying point for rejecting the Ordinary Form and, in some cases, the teachings of Vatican II. Pope Francis noted that the concessions granted by his predecessors were exploited to widen the gaps, reinforce the divergences, and encourage disagreements that injure the Church, block her path, and expose her to the peril of division. The aim of Traditionis Custodes was not to eradicate the Extraordinary Form but to regulate its use to ensure it serves the Church’s unity rather than fostering division. The motu proprio mandates that bishops have exclusive competence to authorize the Extraordinary Form in their dioceses, ensuring that groups celebrating it do not reject Vatican II or the legitimacy of the Ordinary Form. It also introduced restrictions, such as prohibiting the use of parish churches for the Extraordinary Form and requiring Vatican approval for newly ordained priests to celebrate it. These measures were intended to curb the growth of parallel liturgical communities that sometimes operated as a church within a church. Ideologies Within Traditionalist Circles While many Catholics who prefer the Extraordinary Form are devout and faithful to the Church, a vocal minority within traditionalist circles espouses ideologies that have caused significant concern. These ideologies, which Traditionis Custodes sought to address, include division, rejection of Vatican II, sede vacantism, attacks on the papacy, and, in some cases, troubling attitudes such as antisemitism, racism, and Eurocentrism. Below, I explore these issues to provide a clearer picture of the challenges they pose to the Church’s unity. Division and Rejection of Vatican II One of the primary concerns cited by Pope Francis was the use of the Extraordinary Form to foster division within the Church. Some traditionalist communities have positioned the Extraordinary Form as superior to the Ordinary Form, claiming it is the only true expression of Catholic worship. This attitude often extends to a broader rejection of the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965), which introduced liturgical reforms, including the Ordinary Form, to make the Mass more accessible to the faithful through vernacular languages and greater participation. The rejection of Vatican II is not universal among traditionalists, but it is a significant issue in certain circles. Some groups argue that the council’s reforms betrayed Catholic tradition, asserting that the Ordinary Form is less reverent or even invalid. This stance undermines the authority of the council, which Pope Francis described as an act of the Holy Spirit guiding the Church. By rejecting Vatican II, these groups risk creating a parallel ecclesial reality, detached from the broader Church and its magisterium. Sede Vacantism and Attacks on the Papacy A more extreme ideology within some traditionalist factions is sede vacantism, the belief that the papal see is vacant because recent popes, including Pope Francis, are not legitimate successors to St. Peter. This view often stems from a rejection of Vatican II and the liturgical reforms, with adherents claiming that popes who support these changes have fallen into heresy. Such beliefs directly challenge the Church’s unity and the authority of the papacy, fostering a schismatic mentality. Attacks on the papacy are not limited to sede vacantism. Some traditionalists, while not formally denying the pope’s legitimacy, engage in harsh criticism of Pope Francis, accusing him of undermining tradition or leading the Church astray. These attacks often appear on social media platforms and in traditionalist publications, where the pope is portrayed as an enemy of orthodoxy. This rhetoric not only deepens division but also contradicts the Catholic principle of filial obedience to the Holy Father. Antisemitism, Racism, and Eurocentrism Perhaps the most troubling ideologies associated with some traditionalist groups are antisemitism, racism, and Eurocentrism. While these are not representative of all traditionalists, they have surfaced in certain communities and demand attention. Antisemitism, for instance, has historical roots in some pre-Vatican II liturgical practices, such as prayers in the Extraordinary Form that referred to Jews in derogatory terms (e.g., the Good Friday prayer for the perfidious Jews, which was revised by Pope John XXIII). Although these texts have been modified, some traditionalist groups cling to older versions or express views that echo historical prejudices, rejecting Vatican II’s document Nostra Aetate, which condemned antisemitism and promoted respect for other religions. Racism and Eurocentrism also appear in certain traditionalist circles, often tied to a nostalgic view of the Church as a predominantly European institution. Some groups emphasize the Latin language and pre-Vatican II practices as inherently superior, dismissing the cultural diversity of the global Church. This Eurocentric mindset can manifest as a resistance to inculturation—the adaptation of the liturgy to local cultures—as called for by Vatican II. Such attitudes marginalize non-European Catholics and undermine the Church’s universal mission. Backwardness and Resistance to Modernity Pope Francis has described the preference for the Extraordinary Form in some circles as indietrismo or backwardness, a nostalgic attachment to the past that resists the Church’s engagement with the modern world. This backwardness is not merely a preference for traditional liturgy but a broader rejection of the Church’s call to dialogue with contemporary society, as articulated in Vatican II’s Gaudium et Spes. Some traditionalists view modernity itself as inherently corrupt, advocating for a return to a perceived golden age of Catholicism, often idealized as the pre-Vatican II era. This resistance to modernity can lead to a fortress mentality, where traditionalist communities isolate themselves from the broader Church and society. While the desire for reverence and tradition is understandable, this approach risks alienating the faithful from the Church’s mission to evangelize in the present day. It also fosters a sense of superiority, where adherents see themselves as guardians of the true Church against a supposedly compromised institution. Addressing Claims of Dishonesty: The Diane Montagna Controversy In July 2025, Vatican journalist Diane Montagna published excerpts from a leaked Vatican report on her Substack, claiming they exposed major cracks in the rationale for Traditionis Custodes. Montagna argued that the 2020 survey of bishops, conducted by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, showed that the majority of bishops were satisfied with Summorum Pontificum and believed that restricting the Extraordinary Form would cause more harm than good. She suggested that Pope Francis misrepresented the survey results to justify his decision, implying a lack of transparency or honesty. These claims, however, are misleading and require careful scrutiny. The Vatican, through spokesman Matteo Bruni, responded on July 3, 2025, stating that the leaked documents provided a very partial and incomplete reconstruction of the decision-making process. Bruni noted that other reports and consultations, not included in Montagna’s excerpts, informed Pope Francis’ decision. The Dicastery for Divine Worship also declined to comment further, indicating that the leaked documents did not tell the full story. Montagna’s assertion that the survey results were overwhelmingly positive ignores the complexity of the bishops’ responses. While some bishops reported satisfaction with Summorum Pontificum, others expressed concerns about division, rejection of Vatican II, and the formation of isolated communities around the Extraordinary Form. The leaked report itself acknowledged that some bishops viewed the Extraordinary Form as inappropriate, disturbing, and even dangerous in certain contexts. Pope Francis never claimed that a majority of bishops explicitly requested restrictions; rather, he stated that the survey revealed a situation that preoccupies and saddens him, prompting the need for intervention. By presenting a selective narrative, Montagna’s claims risk fueling division rather than fostering understanding. The accusation that Pope Francis acted dishonestly overlooks the broader context of his decision, including his pastoral concern for the Church’s unity and his responsibility to address issues that threaten it. The leaked documents, while informative, do not negate the evidence of problematic ideologies within some traditionalist communities, which Traditionis Custodes sought to address. See more here: Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna On World Over - Vetting Her Claims The Unlikelihood of Pope Leo XIV Rescinding Traditionis Custodes Since his election, Pope Leo XIV has emphasized unity and reconciliation as central themes of his pontificate. Some traditionalists have expressed hope that he might reverse or moderate Traditionis Custodes, citing his stated desire to heal divisions. However, several factors suggest that a full rescission of the motu proprio is unlikely. First, Traditionis Custodes aligns with the broader trajectory of the Church’s liturgical renewal since Vatican II. The Ordinary Form, promulgated by St. Paul VI and revised by St. John Paul II, is considered the unique expression of the lex orandi of the Roman Rite in Traditionis Custodes. This reflects a theological and pastoral commitment to the liturgical reforms of Vatican II, which Pope Leo XIV, as a successor to Peter, is unlikely to undermine. Reversing the motu proprio would signal a retreat from this commitment, potentially reigniting liturgical debates that the Church has sought to resolve. Second, the issues Traditionis Custodes addresses—division, rejection of Vatican II, and ideological misuse of the Extraordinary Form—remain relevant. While some traditionalists argue that the motu proprio has exacerbated tensions, others acknowledge that it has prompted necessary reflection within traditionalist communities about their relationship with the broader Church. Pope Leo XIV may choose to adjust the implementation of Traditionis Custodes, such as granting more exemptions for dioceses to celebrate the Extraordinary Form, but a complete reversal would risk legitimizing the problematic ideologies that prompted the original decree. Third, Pope Leo XIV’s focus on unity suggests he will prioritize dialogue over drastic policy shifts. For example, the recent extension of permission for the Extraordinary Form in the Diocese of San Angelo, Texas, indicates that the Vatican under Leo XIV is open to pastoral accommodations where they do not undermine unity. However, these accommodations are likely to be case-specific rather than a blanket rescission of Traditionis Custodes. Finally, the Church’s magisterial authority rests on continuity with its councils and popes. Rescinding Traditionis Custodes would not only contradict Pope Francis’ legacy but also risk destabilizing the Church’s liturgical framework. Pope Leo XIV, as a new pontiff, is more likely to seek a balanced approach, encouraging reverence in all liturgical celebrations while upholding the Ordinary Form as the primary expression of the Roman Rite. A Path Forward: Unity in Diversity As a traditionalist who cherishes the Extraordinary Form, I recognize the beauty and reverence it brings to worship. Yet, I also see the wisdom in Traditionis Custodes. The Church is not a museum preserving a single liturgical form but a living body guided by the Holy Spirit. The Ordinary Form, when celebrated with reverence, embodies the spirit of Vatican II’s call for active participation and evangelization. The Extraordinary Form, when celebrated in communion with the Church, can enrich this mission, but it must not become a source of division or ideological rigidity. The fourth anniversary of Traditionis Custodes invites us to reflect on our role as Catholics in fostering unity. Traditionalists must confront the problematic ideologies within their ranks—division, rejection of Vatican II, sede vacantism, attacks on the papacy, antisemitism, racism, and Eurocentrism—and work to root them out. These attitudes not only harm the Church but also betray the very tradition they claim to uphold. At the same time, bishops and pastors must approach traditionalist communities with pastoral sensitivity, recognizing that many are simply seeking reverence and continuity in their worship. Pope Leo XIV has an opportunity to bridge divides, but this will require dialogue, not rescission. The Church must continue to affirm the validity of Vatican II and the Ordinary Form while allowing space for the Extraordinary Form where it fosters unity rather than division. As Catholics, we are called to love the liturgy without making it an idol, to honor tradition without rejecting the present, and to follow the Holy Father without losing sight of our shared mission to proclaim the Gospel. In conclusion, Traditionis Custodes was not an attack on tradition but a call to safeguard the Church’s unity. Its fourth anniversary reminds us that the path forward lies in humility, charity, and fidelity to the Church’s living tradition. Let us pray for Pope Leo XIV, for our bishops, and for all Catholics, that we may worship together in harmony, united in the one sacrifice of Christ. Citations:

- Vatican spokesman: Traditionis custodes leak very partial - www.pillarcatholic.com

- Vatican downplays leaked documents on Latin Mass | Catholic News Agency - www.catholicnewsagency.com

- Latin Mass debate grows after apparent leak of Vatican liturgy report | America Magazine - www.americamagazine.org

- Traditionis custodes - Wikipedia - en.wikipedia.org

- Pope Francis says traditional Latin Mass was being used in an ideological way | Catholic News Agency - www.catholicnewsagency.com

- Pope Leo XIV Faces an Early Challenge: How to Deal With Pope Francis’ Restrictions on the Latin Mass | National Catholic Register - www.ncregister.com

- Apostolic Letter issued Motu proprio by the Supreme Pontiff Francis Traditionis custodes on the use of the Roman Liturgy prior to ... - www.vatican.va

- Letter of the Holy Father to the Bishops of the whole world, that accompanies the Apostolic Letter Motu Proprio data Traditionis custodes ... - www.vatican.va

- New norms regarding use of 1962 Roman Missal: Bishops given greater responsibility - Vatican News - www.vaticannews.va

- EXCLUSIVE: Official Vatican Report Exposes Major Cracks in Foundation of Traditionis Custodes - dianemontagna.substack.com

- Traditionis Custodes Was Never Merely About the Liturgy | Church Life Journal | University of Notre Dame - churchlifejournal.nd.edu

- Reflections from France on the motu proprio Traditionis Custodes of Pope Francis – Catholic World Report - www.catholicworldreport.com

Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Diane Montagna On World Over - Vetting Her Claims

Below is a detailed, fact-based response addressing the claims made in the YouTube video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DzR03WoPh20) by Diane Montagna, published on July 1, 2025, regarding the leaked Vatican documents related to Traditionis Custodes. The response will refute the video’s claims, focusing on the lack of verification of the leak’s source, the questionable validity of the protocol number, the misrepresentation of Pope Francis’ use of the 2020 bishops’ survey, Montagna’s potential bias, and her grandiose assertions about divine guidance. Additionally, it will address her interactions with the Sacerdotus ministry account and the Vatican’s use of protocol numbers, including their accessibility. Introduction The YouTube video of EWTN's The World Over with Diane Montagna as a guest of Raymond Arroyo, published on July 1, 2025, presents leaked documents purportedly from the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), which she claims undermine the rationale for Pope Francis’ 2021 motu proprio, Traditionis Custodes. This decree restricted the celebration of the Extraordinary Form, reversing permissions granted by Pope Benedict XVI in Summorum Pontificum (2007). Montagna asserts that the leaked documents, including a protocol number, reveal that most bishops surveyed in 2020 supported Summorum Pontificum and opposed restrictions on the Extraordinary Form, contradicting Pope Francis’ stated reasons for issuing Traditionis Custodes. She further suggests that her publication of these documents is divinely inspired to influence Pope Leo XIV to reconsider the restrictions. This response refutes Montagna’s claims by addressing the following points:

1. The lack of verified authenticity of the leaked documents and the protocol number. 2. The misrepresentation of Pope Francis’ reliance on the 2020 survey. 3. The potential bias in Montagna’s reporting, including her interactions with the Sacerdotus ministry account. 4. The claim of divine guidance as evidence of grandiosity. 5. The Vatican’s use of protocol numbers and their accessibility to the public. The response draws on credible sources, including Vatican statements and Catholic media, while critically examining the establishment narrative to ensure balance. --- Lack of Verified Authenticity of the Leaked Documents and Protocol Number The Documents and Their Source Montagna claims to have obtained internal Vatican documents, including a five-page overall assessment of a 2020 bishops’ survey and a seven-page compilation of bishops’ quotes, prepared by the CDF’s Fourth Section (formerly the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei). These documents allegedly show that most bishops supported Summorum Pontificum and warned that restricting the Extraordinary Form would cause harm. In a follow-up Substack post, Montagna claims to have obtained the protocol number for the CDF’s final report, asserting it confirms the documents’ authenticity as the official opinion of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith referenced in Traditionis Custodes. However, the authenticity of these documents remains unverified. Vatican spokesman Matteo Bruni, when questioned on July 3, 2025, during a press conference, declined to confirm their authenticity, stating that they presumably concern part of one of the documents on which the decision to restrict the Extraordinary Form was based and constitute a very partial and incomplete reconstruction of the decision-making process. Bruni’s refusal to authenticate the documents casts doubt on their legitimacy. The Protocol Number’s Validity Montagna’s claim that the protocol number verifies the documents’ authenticity is problematic. Protocol numbers are internal identifiers used by Vatican dicasteries to track official documents, but they are not inherently proof of authenticity when presented by an external party. Without access to the Vatican’s internal filing system, no outsider, including Montagna, can independently verify whether a given protocol number corresponds to a specific document. The Vatican’s archival processes are highly confidential, and protocol numbers are not typically accessible to the public for verification (see the section on Vatican protocol numbers below). Thus, Montagna’s presentation of a protocol number does not constitute proof, as anyone could fabricate such a number without a mechanism for public validation. Moreover, Montagna does not provide evidence of how she verified the protocol number. Her Substack post mentions obtaining the number but lacks details on its source or corroboration. Without an official Vatican statement or access to internal records, the protocol number remains an unverified claim. The burden of proof lies with Montagna, and her failure to provide transparent verification undermines her assertion that the documents are authentic. As Bruni noted, the leaked texts are likely only a partial representation of the broader consultation process, suggesting that Montagna’s documents may not fully reflect the Vatican’s internal deliberations. Insider Verification Challenges Montagna’s claim that the documents are authentic because they include a protocol number assumes that only an insider could provide such details. However, this logic is flawed. While an insider might have access to protocol numbers, the absence of public access to Vatican archives means that no one outside the Vatican can confirm the number’s legitimacy. Even if an insider leaked the documents, their motivations (e.g., advancing a traditionalist agenda) could introduce bias, and the documents could be selectively edited or incomplete. The lack of letterhead, signatures, or other official markers in the leaked texts further raises questions about their integrity. The Vatican’s silence on the documents’ authenticity, beyond Bruni’s cautious statement, suggests a deliberate choice to avoid validating unverified leaks. This is consistent with the Vatican’s practice of maintaining confidentiality in internal processes, especially when sensitive liturgical decisions are involved. Montagna’s insistence on the protocol number as proof is speculative and lacks substantiation. --- Misrepresentation of Pope Francis’ Reliance on the 2020 Survey Montagna’s Claim In the video, Montagna asserts that Pope Francis claimed his decision to issue Traditionis Custodes was based solely on the 2020 bishops’ survey, which she alleges showed widespread support for Summorum Pontificum. She argues that the leaked documents prove Francis misrepresented the survey results, as the majority of bishops reportedly opposed restrictions on the Extraordinary Form. Refutation: Pope Francis’ Broader Evidence Base This claim misrepresents Pope Francis’ statements. In his letter accompanying Traditionis Custodes, Francis wrote that the survey responses reveal a situation that preoccupies and saddens me, and persuades me of the need to intervene, citing the bishops’ feedback and the opinion of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. However, he never stated that the survey was his sole source of evidence. Bruni clarified on July 3, 2025, that the decision was informed by other documentation, other confidential reports, and subsequent consultations received by the CDF. This indicates a broader decision-making process, including reserved reports and internal deliberations, which Francis had no obligation to disclose publicly due to their confidential nature. Montagna’s assertion that Francis relied only on the survey is a strawman argument. The leaked documents, even if authentic, represent only a portion of the evidence considered. The Vatican’s assessment process likely included qualitative and quantitative data, anecdotal reports, and consultations with dicastery officials, which may have highlighted concerns about liturgical division or misuse of the Extraordinary Form to challenge Vatican II reforms. Francis’ letter emphasized that the Extraordinary Form had been exploited to widen the gaps, reinforce the divergences, and encourage disagreements that injure the Church, suggesting that his decision was motivated by pastoral concerns beyond the survey’s scope. Bishops’ Confidentiality Concerns Montagna’s claim that the survey results contradict Francis’ rationale overlooks the possibility that bishops may have provided confidential feedback not reflected in the leaked documents. Many bishops might have been reluctant to publicly oppose the Extraordinary Form due to potential backlash from traditionalist groups in their dioceses, as noted in the query. The Extraordinary Form debate is highly polarized, particularly in regions like the United States, where traditionalist communities are vocal and influential. Bishops may have expressed concerns about division or schism in private consultations, which would not appear in a public-facing summary. The Vatican’s decision to keep such reports confidential aligns with standard ecclesiastical practice to protect bishops from public scrutiny and maintain unity. By focusing solely on the leaked excerpts, Montagna ignores the broader context of the Vatican’s decision-making process. Her claim that Francis was caught in a lie (as suggested by some commentators) is speculative and unsupported by evidence, as it assumes the leaked documents represent the entirety of the Vatican’s considerations. --- Montagna’s Potential Bias and Interactions with Sacerdotus Evidence of Bias Montagna’s reporting exhibits a clear bias toward traditionalist perspectives. Her Substack newsletter and video emphasize the leaked documents’ support for Summorum Pontificum while downplaying or omitting negative or neutral bishops’ responses included in the documents. For example, the leaked texts note that some bishops found Summorum Pontificum inappropriate, disturbing, or worthy of suppression, but Montagna’s narrative focuses almost exclusively on the positive feedback. This selective presentation suggests an agenda to bolster traditionalist arguments against Traditionis Custodes. Her affiliations and past reporting further indicate bias. Montagna has closely followed the Extraordinary Form dispute since Traditionis Custodes and is associated with outlets like OnePeterFive, which advocate for traditionalist causes. Her framing of the leaks as exposing major cracks in the Vatican’s rationale aligns with traditionalist rhetoric, as seen in comments from Joseph Shaw of the Latin Mass Society, who praised her work. This suggests that Montagna’s reporting may prioritize advocacy over objective journalism. Interactions with Sacerdotus Montagna blocked the Sacerdotus ministry account on X and Substack after challenges to her claims, demonstrating that she could not address the refutations and sought to suppress them. This aligns with a pattern of defensive behavior among some journalists when faced with criticism. Montagna’s decision to block Sacerdotus could indicate an unwillingness to engage with counterarguments, further suggesting bias. By limiting dialogue with critics, she may be curating an echo chamber that amplifies traditionalist sentiments while avoiding scrutiny. Her failure to publicly address criticisms like those raised in the query reinforces perceptions of selective reporting. It indicates that her claims cannot withstand scrutiny and vetting. They are most likely false. Any journalist with a hit story that is strongly supported with incontrovertible evidence will not resort to blocking skeptics of it who refute it. --- Claims of Divine Guidance and Grandiosity: Delusional Mind Montagna’s Assertions In the video, Montagna insinuates that her publication of the leaked documents is part of a divine plan to influence Pope Leo XIV to reverse Traditionis Custodes. This claim, echoed in her Substack posts, suggests a grandiose view of her role as a journalist, positioning her as a divinely guided actor in ecclesiastical matters. Such assertions lack objective grounding and rely on subjective interpretation, which undermines her credibility as a neutral reporter. Refutation Claims of divine guidance are inherently unverifiable and inappropriate in journalistic reporting, which demands evidence-based conclusions. Montagna’s suggestion that God led her to publish the leaks to influence Pope Leo XIV reflects a personal agenda rather than a commitment to factual reporting. This rhetoric aligns with traditionalist narratives that frame the Extraordinary Form debate as a spiritual battle, but it lacks substantiation and risks alienating readers who value objectivity. Moreover, Montagna’s focus on Pope Leo XIV’s potential response to the leaks assumes that he will prioritize traditionalist concerns based on her disclosures. However, Pope Leo XIV has emphasized unity and reconciliation, and there is no evidence that he intends to reverse Traditionis Custodes. Her speculative framing of the leaks as a catalyst for papal action exaggerates her influence and the documents’ significance, further indicating a grandiose perspective. --- Vatican Protocol Numbers and Public Accessibility Use of Protocol Numbers The Vatican uses protocol numbers to catalog official documents within its dicasteries, such as the CDF or the Dicastery for Divine Worship. These numbers serve as internal identifiers for tracking correspondence, reports, and decrees. For example, a protocol number might include a year and a sequential identifier (e.g., Prot. N. 123/2020). These numbers are typically included on official documents to ensure proper filing and retrieval within the Vatican’s archives. However, protocol numbers are not publicly accessible for verification. The Vatican’s archival system is highly confidential, and access to internal records is restricted to authorized personnel, such as dicastery officials or archivists. The Vatican Apostolic Archives (formerly the Vatican Secret Archives) houses sensitive documents, but public access is limited and requires special permission, often granted only for historical research on older records. Verification Challenges As noted earlier, Montagna’s presentation of a protocol number does not constitute proof of authenticity, as it cannot be independently verified by the public. Only Vatican insiders with access to the relevant dicastery’s records could confirm whether a protocol number corresponds to a specific document. Even then, the lack of public disclosure of such records means that Montagna’s claim relies on trust in her source, which she does not disclose. This opacity undermines her assertion that the protocol number validates the documents. The Vatican’s practice of maintaining confidentiality in its internal processes explains why Bruni and other officials have not confirmed the documents’ authenticity. Releasing protocol numbers or related records could compromise ongoing deliberations or expose sensitive information, such as bishops’ confidential feedback. Thus, Montagna’s reliance on the protocol number as evidence is insufficient without official corroboration. --- Additional Considerations: The Broader Context The Extraordinary Form Debate and Vatican Decision-Making The debate over the Extraordinary Form is complex and involves theological, pastoral, and cultural dimensions. Pope Francis’ decision to issue Traditionis Custodes was motivated by concerns about liturgical unity and the potential for the Extraordinary Form to be used to challenge Vatican II’s reforms. The leaked documents, even if partially authentic, do not negate the possibility that other evidence—such as reports of division in specific dioceses or concerns about schismatic groups—justified Francis’ actions. Montagna’s focus on the survey’s positive feedback ignores the broader pastoral context. For example, the documents note that some bishops supported returning to pre-2007 rules requiring episcopal permission for the Extraordinary Form, indicating a desire for greater control to manage local tensions. This suggests a diversity of opinions among bishops, which Montagna’s selective reporting downplays. Implications for Pope Leo XIV Montagna’s hope that the leaks will prompt Pope Leo XIV to reverse Traditionis Custodes is speculative. While Leo has emphasized unity, there is no indication that he views the Extraordinary Form restrictions as a priority for revision. The leaks may pressure traditionalist groups to advocate more vocally, but the Vatican’s cautious response suggests that any policy changes will be deliberate and based on broader consultations, not unverified leaks. --- Conclusion Diane Montagna’s claims in the YouTube video lack credibility due to several critical flaws:

1. The leaked documents and their protocol number remain unverified, with no public mechanism to confirm their authenticity. Matteo Bruni’s refusal to authenticate them underscores their questionable status.

2. Montagna misrepresents Pope Francis’ reliance on the 2020 survey, ignoring his reference to broader evidence, including confidential reports, which he was not obligated to disclose.

3. Her reporting exhibits bias toward traditionalist perspectives, as evidenced by selective presentation of the leaked documents and her affiliations with traditionalist outlets. Her blocking of the Sacerdotus account suggests an unwillingness to engage with critics and defend her claims. They do not withstand scrutiny if she feels the need to block (Sacerdotus: Diana Montagna Blocks Sacerdotus on X After Refutation of Her Claims on Pope Francis: A Sign of Weak Journalism?). 

4. Her assertion of divine guidance is grandiose and inappropriate for objective journalism, undermining her credibility.

5. Vatican protocol numbers are internal and not publicly verifiable, rendering Montagna’s use of one as proof invalid without official corroboration. The Vatican’s use of protocol numbers is standard but restricted to internal processes, and public access to such records is limited. Montagna’s claims rely on unverified assumptions and selective reporting, failing to meet the standards of objective journalism. While the Extraordinary Form debate remains significant, her video does not provide conclusive evidence to challenge Traditionis Custodes or influence Pope Leo XIV’s policies. Critical examination of her claims reveals a narrative driven by advocacy rather than fact, and the Vatican’s response appropriately prioritizes confidentiality and due process.




Sources:

- Catholic News Agency, Vatican downplays leaked documents on Extraordinary Form, July 3, 2025.

- Catholic World Report, Vatican downplays leaked documents on Extraordinary Form, July 2, 2025.

- AP News, Vatican says leaked documents were only part of information Pope Francis used to restrict Extraordinary Form, July 2, 2025.

- The Pillar, Vatican spokesman: Traditionis Custodes leak very partial, July 3, 2025.

- OnePeterFive, New Leak Challenges the Vatican Narrative (Again), July 10, 2025.

- Novus Ordo Watch, Leaked Vatican Documents Undermine Francis’ Stated Rationale for Suppressing Extraordinary Form, July 3, 2025.

- OSV News, Vatican says documents on Extraordinary Form assessment incomplete, July 3, 2025.

- @CatholicSat, July 3, 2025.

- @EdwardPentin, July 3, 2025.

- @DrKwasniewski, July 10, 2025.

Sacerdotus: Critical Analysis of Diane Montagna's Article and Claims Regarding Traditionis Custodes

Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna Rehashes the Same Lies

Sacerdotus: Diane Montagna & 'Traditionalists' Lied about Pope Francis

Sacerdotus: Diana Montagna Blocks Sacerdotus on X After Refutation of Her Claims on Pope Francis: A Sign of Weak Journalism?

Sacerdotus TV LIveStream

Labels

Catholic Church (1646) Jesus (766) God (755) Bible (622) Atheism (400) Jesus Christ (378) Pope Francis (347) Liturgy of the Word (326) Apologetics (301) Atheist (280) Science (239) Christianity (203) Theology (152) LGBT (148) Liturgy (139) Blessed Virgin Mary (129) Prayer (99) Abortion (97) Gay (95) Philosophy (93) Pope Benedict XVI (93) Traditionalists (84) Rosa Rubicondior (82) Vatican (77) Psychology (75) Physics (74) Christmas (64) New York City (62) Holy Eucharist (61) Christian (60) President Obama (59) Protestant (53) Vatican II (51) Health (49) Biology (48) Gospel (47) Politics (47) Women (44) Racism (40) Supreme Court (35) Baseball (34) Death (34) Pope John Paul II (33) Illegal Immigrants (32) NYPD (32) priests (32) Priesthood (29) Morality (28) Space (28) Astrophysics (27) Eucharist (27) Jewish (27) Religious Freedom (27) Donald Trump (25) Evangelization (25) Christ (22) Evil (22) First Amendment (21) Pro Abortion (19) Child Abuse (17) Divine Mercy (17) Marriage (17) Pedophilia (17) Pro Choice (17) Easter Sunday (16) Holy Trinity (16) Police (16) Pentecostals (15) Sacraments (15) Angels (14) Autism (14) Gender Theory (14) Poverty (13) September 11 (13) Blog (12) CUNY (12) Cognitive Psychology (12) Muslims (12) academia (12) Hispanics (11) Pope Paul VI (11) Evangelicals (10) Massimo Pigliucci (10) Personhood (10) Evidence (9) Hell (9) Podcast (9) Barack Obama (8) Big Bang Theory (8) Human Rights (8) Humanism (8) Condoms (7) David Viviano (7) Death penalty (7) Eastern Orthodox (7) Ellif_dwulfe (7) NY Yankees (7) Spiritual Life (7) Encyclical (6) Gender Dysphoria Disorder (6) Babies (5) Baby Jesus (5) Catholic Bloggers (5) Cyber Bullying (5) Donations (5) Pope Pius XII (5) The Walking Dead (5) Ephebophilia (4) Plenary Indulgence (4) Pluto (4) Pope John XXIII (4) Founding Fathers (3) Dan Arel (2) Freeatheism (2) Oxfam (2) Penn Jillette (2) Pew Research Center (2) Cursillo (1) Dan Savage (1) Divine Providence (1) Fear The Walking Dead (1) Pentecostales (1)